Skip to content
Crypto.world

Policy & Regulation

Where the Scam Cashes Out: Why Warnings Failed at Crypto ATMs

Fraud at crypto kiosks is a design problem that warning screens did not fix. What Minnesota tried before banning the machines, what the FBI and regulators recorded, and why refunds paid by operators…

Where the Scam Cashes Out: Why Warnings Failed at Crypto ATMs

How a Kiosk Scam Cashes Out, and Why the Warning Loses

In the typical kiosk scam, the victim does not reach the machine alone. The scammer explains how to withdraw cash, where to find a kiosk and which QR code to scan, then talks the victim through the deposit, "often staying in constant online or phone communication with the victim and providing step-by-step instructions until the payment is completed," in the words of notice FIN-2025-NTC1, issued on 4 August 2025 by the US Treasury's Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN). A warning on the screen competes with a voice the victim already trusts.

Fraud at these machines is a design problem, and warnings do not fix it, as Minnesota found. In 2024 the state required a bold fraud warning, capped new customers at $2,000 a day and offered refunds only for a new customer's first 72 hours; in May 2026 it banned the machines from 1 August 2026 and repealed those rules. Short of a ban, the lever that changes an operator's behavior is its own money, because the operator collects a fee on every deposit, fraudulent ones included.

Refunds paid by the operator put the loss where the fee is. Vermont required them from July 2025 until it banned the machines a year later; South Dakota has required a full refund for any fraud victim who reports within 90 days since July 2026; North Carolina's version starts on 1 January 2027. Whether refunds change how operators screen deposits is still an open question.

:::callout-note In one minute: Scammers coach victims through the kiosk by phone, so the warning appears while the scammer is still talking. The FBI logged 13,460 kiosk-related complaints and $388,981,267 in adjusted losses for 2025; more than half involved people over 50. Minnesota's cap, warning and 72-hour refund left most losses with victims, and the state banned kiosks from 1 August 2026. Indiana and Tennessee also banned them, and so did Vermont, a year after it made operators refund fraud victims; Hawaii barred kiosks that accept US currency for crypto from 1 October 2026. South Dakota (from 1 July 2026) and North Carolina (from 1 January 2027) chose limits and operator-paid refunds; North Carolina adds a 48-hour hold. :::

FinCEN's notice lists the scripts. The most common kiosk typology is the tech or customer support scam, in which callers posing as well-known companies claim a computer has been compromised. Others pose as the victim's bank, a government agency, a romantic partner, a relative in trouble or a sweepstakes. Scammers tell victims to break cash into several smaller deposits, which the notice says may constitute structuring, or to split the payment across several kiosks, a tactic it calls "smurfing," and they often come back for more.

Once the deposit goes through, the notice says, the scammer "instantly owns" the coins, while a bank or wire transfer can remain pending for one to two days. Scammers accept kiosk fees of 7 to 20 percent for that speed. FinCEN Director Andrea Gacki said: "Criminals are relentless in their efforts to steal money from victims, and they’ve learned to exploit innovative technologies like CVC kiosks."

Older adults carry much of the loss. "Criminals targeting older individuals are particularly likely to direct victims to use CVC kiosks to send payments," the notice says. It cites Federal Trade Commission data: people aged 60 and over were more than three times as likely as younger adults to report a loss using a kiosk, and more than two of every three dollars reported lost to kiosk fraud was lost by an older adult.

13,460 Complaints in One Year: The FBI's Count for 2025

The FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) published state-level kiosk data on 15 May 2026, in public service announcement I-051526-PSA. For 2025 it counted 13,460 complaints involving cryptocurrency kiosks and $388,981,267 in adjusted losses, a 23% increase in complaints and a 58% increase in losses from 2024. More than half of the complaints involved people over 50, whose losses were over $302 million.

By state, Texas had the highest 2025 losses, $56,802,197 from 1,179 complaints, while Florida had the most complaints, 1,213, with $32,765,444 in losses. Minnesota logged 222 complaints and $4,067,720. The FBI adds a caveat to every figure: complaints may include other kinds of transactions, so "overall losses cannot be solely attributed to cryptocurrency kiosks, but to scams involving the use of cryptocurrency kiosks as well as other types of transactions."

One Operator's Record: What D.C. Alleges Against Athena Bitcoin

The most detailed record of a single operator is an allegation, not a finding. On 8 September 2025 the District of Columbia's Attorney General, Brian Schwalb, sued Athena Bitcoin in D.C. Superior Court under the District's consumer protection and elder financial exploitation laws. The complaint says Athena maintained seven machines in the District.

Its central number comes from Athena's own data. An analysis of complaint and transaction data from its first five months in the District, May to September 2024, found that "at least 93% of all Athena BTM deposits were the product of fraud," the complaint says. The median victim was 71 years old, and the median loss per transaction was $8,000.

The complaint ties the fraud to fees. It alleges undisclosed fees of up to 26% per transaction, against 0.24% to 3% on apps and exchanges, and a policy that capped fee refunds at $7,500: one resident who fed $98,000 into a machine, paying almost $26,000 in fees along the way, got $7,500 back. "Athena knows that its machines are being used primarily by scammers yet chooses to look the other way so that it can continue to pocket sizable hidden transaction fees," Schwalb said.

Warnings are part of the record too. The complaint says Athena's screens carried scam warnings with the directive "REACT BEFORE YOU TRANSACT," and alleges that "Scammers explicitly warn victims not to read the on-screen warnings or tell them that the warnings don’t apply to their situation." Every figure in the case is the District's allegation, not a ruling of the court.

Minnesota's Test: A Bold Warning, a $2,000 Cap, Then a Ban

Minnesota's kiosk rules took effect on 1 August 2024, according to the state Commerce Department, as section 53B.75 of Minnesota Statutes. Operators had to disclose on screen the risks, the fees and the gap between their price and the market price. A separate warning, "written prominently and in bold type," had to be acknowledged by every customer, and the law fixed its words:

:::callout-warning The warning Minnesota required, 2024 to 2026: "WARNING: LOSSES DUE TO FRAUDULENT OR ACCIDENTAL TRANSACTIONS ARE NOT RECOVERABLE AND TRANSACTIONS IN VIRTUAL CURRENCY ARE IRREVERSIBLE. VIRTUAL CURRENCY TRANSACTIONS MAY BE USED BY SCAMMERS IMPERSONATING LOVED ONES, THREATENING JAIL TIME, AND INSISTING YOU WITHDRAW MONEY FROM YOUR BANK ACCOUNT TO PURCHASE VIRTUAL CURRENCY." :::

Two more rules covered new customers, meaning anyone who had been a customer of an operator for less than 72 hours. A new customer could deposit no more than $2,000 a day. One who had been fraudulently induced was owed a full refund of all transactions in those 72 hours, if the victim told both the operator and a government or law enforcement agency within 14 days of the last one. Limits for existing customers were left to each operator.

The state's own evidence says scammers beat the design. At a House Commerce Finance and Policy Committee hearing on 26 February 2026, Sam Smith, the Commerce Department's government relations director, said the department had received 70 kiosk complaints in 2025 totaling $540,000 in losses, according to the House's Session Daily. Forty-eight percent of consumers received a refund, he said, and those refunds averaged 16% of their total loss.

Smith said scammers got around the 2024 safeguards by having victims make several small deposits, click past warnings and disclosures, and avoid the new-customer provision. Session Daily quoted his verdict: "Previous efforts to increase consumer protections for crypto kiosks have failed." Its account of the hearing adds that scammers tell victims to enter cash under an existing customer number, and a Woodbury police detective said that because of the law some victims had been sent to a kiosk in Wisconsin.

The department's release of 14 May 2026 counted 134 kiosk-scam complaints from 2023 to 2025, with nearly $1 million in reported losses. Sara Payne, Commerce's assistant commissioner for enforcement, said the 2024 reforms had been "fairly ineffective" as fraudsters found ways around the caps and the warnings, the Star Tribune reported.

The Legislature then replaced the rules with a ban. Laws 2026, chapter 65 (S.F. 3868), signed on 5 May 2026, bars anyone from installing, operating, maintaining or making available a kiosk from 1 August 2026 and requires machines to be removed from public view by 31 December 2026. The 2024 warning, disclosure and cap provisions were repealed from 1 August 2026; repeal of the refund provision takes effect on 17 January 2027.

Bans, Caps and Refunds Elsewhere

Three other states chose full bans in 2026, and Hawaii a narrower one. Indiana's House Enrolled Act 1116, signed on 9 March 2026 and effective on passage, says: "A person may not operate a virtual currency kiosk in Indiana." A court that finds a knowing violation may order the operator to forfeit to the state the charges it collected from users. Tennessee's Public Chapter 766 (House Bill 2505), signed on 13 April 2026, makes it a Class A misdemeanor to knowingly install or operate a kiosk from 1 July 2026.

Vermont has the longest record. Its 2024 law paired a moratorium on new kiosks with a $1,000 daily cap and a fee cap of the greater of $5 or 3% of the transaction. In June 2024 the state's largest kiosk operator, with 33 registered machines, surrendered its license, and kiosk transactions fell by more than 96% from the second to the third quarter of 2024, the Department of Financial Regulation reported.

Act 23, signed on 19 May 2025 and in force from 1 July 2025, extended the moratorium a year, set daily limits of $2,000 for new and $5,000 for existing customers and raised the fee cap to the greater of $5 or 15%. Defrauded new customers, those within 30 days of a first transaction, were owed a full refund and existing ones their fees, if they told the operator and a law enforcement or government agency within 90 days. Act 142, signed on 16 June 2026, banned kiosks from 1 July 2026.

Hawaii's Act 224 (House Bill 1642), signed by Governor Josh Green on 9 July 2026, goes after the deposit alone. From 1 October 2026 it is an unlawful practice to own, operate or manage a kiosk that accepts US currency in exchange for a digital financial asset, each transaction a separate offense. Machines that take a digital asset for US currency or another digital asset stay lawful. The act's findings echo FinCEN: the scammer "stays in constant contact with the prospective victim until the payment is completed."

Outside the United States, regulators have leaned toward limits. Australia's AUSTRAC announced in June 2025 a A$5,000 limit on cash deposits and withdrawals at crypto ATMs, with mandatory scam warnings and stronger customer due diligence. New Zealand's Cabinet agreed in principle in June 2025 to ban the machines, then changed course on 9 July 2026, when Associate Justice Minister Nicole McKee said the government would not proceed with a blanket ban and would instead take powers to restrict cash transactions.

McKee's reason is the industry's own argument: the analysis "found they can have legitimate uses, including for cash-reliant New Zealanders who want to access or invest in virtual assets." Bitcoin Depot described its mission as "to connect those who prefer to use cash to the broader, digital financial system." At Minnesota's February hearing, CoinFlip general counsel Larry Lipka backed refunds for all scam victims instead of a ban, and Session Daily quoted him: "It is inappropriate to ban a legal product because fraud is happening. Not our fault."

South Dakota chose rules over a ban. Its Senate Bill 98, signed in March 2026 and in force from 1 July 2026, caps each user at $1,000 a day and $10,000 over 30 days. A user defrauded at a kiosk is owed a full refund, charges included, if the victim tells the operator within 90 days of the last fraud, or of learning of it, and within 120 days of that contact provides a police or agency report or a sworn statement. The operator then has 72 hours to pay.

North Carolina took the regulatory path too. Session Law 2026-45 (House Bill 920), approved by Governor Josh Stein on 7 July 2026 and effective 1 January 2027, caps daily transactions at $2,000 for a new customer and $5,000 for an existing one, and counts as new anyone whose first transaction was within the past 30 days. Transactions by customers in their first seven days are held for 48 hours before any coins move. Total fees, spread included, may not exceed 12%.

The North Carolina law also redesigns the screens. Each fraud warning must stay up for at least 10 seconds and ask: "Does this fraud warning apply to you or your situation?" A "Yes" ends the transaction and locks the customer's access for at least 24 hours. Log-ins by QR code or barcode are banned. If the Commissioner of Banks determines that a transaction reported within 30 days was fraudulent, the operator refunds the full deposit of a new customer and the fees charged to an existing one.

Who Pays When the Kiosk Is Used for Fraud

An operator earns its fee whether the cash comes from a willing buyer or from a victim coached by a fake bank officer, and under a warning-only regime the loss stays with the customer. Vermont's regulator named the misalignment in a January 2025 report: operators' interest in keeping costs down stays at odds with fraud prevention as long as fraud losses fall on consumers alone, operators profit from fees on fraudulent transactions, and prevention only reduces their profits. Its remedy was refunds.

These refund requirements shift all or a portion of the costs of fraud losses to the kiosk operator, such that it will be in the kiosk operator’s economic interests to prevent fraud losses. — Sandy Bigglestone, Acting Commissioner of Financial Regulation, Vermont Department of Financial Regulation

Vermont's legislature wrote that remedy into law in 2025 and banned the machines in 2026. Minnesota's refund was too narrow to shift much. It covered only a customer's first 72 hours, scammers routed victims around it, and the refunds that were paid averaged 16% of the loss.

North Carolina widens the window to 30 days and holds first-week deposits, but a long scam still escapes it. The Woodbury victim described at the Minnesota hearing had been caught in a scam for eight months; under North Carolina's rule, as under Vermont's, deposits after a customer's first 30 days earn back only the fees. South Dakota's refund has no new-customer window.

The operators' own words point the same way. When Bitcoin Depot announced its bankruptcy, its chief executive listed identity checks, customer fraud warnings and lower limits among the protections it had added. Then he pointed to rules and litigation:

Nevertheless, the regulatory environment for BTM operators has shifted significantly: states have imposed increasingly stringent compliance obligations, including new transaction limits, and in some jurisdictions, outright restrictions or bans on BTM operations; and operators have faced increasing litigation and regulatory enforcement. These developments have materially affected Bitcoin Depot’s business and financial position. Under these circumstances, the Company’s current business model is unsustainable. — Alex Holmes, CEO, Bitcoin Depot

The company and 16 affiliates filed Chapter 11 petitions in the Southern District of Texas on 17 May 2026 "to effect an orderly wind-down of the Company’s operations and facilitate a sale of its assets," its Form 8-K says. The release furnished with that filing describes Bitcoin Depot as having "the largest market share in North America" and says its kiosk network had been taken offline.

Three questions will decide whether refunds work: whether operators that pay for fraud screen harder before money moves, whether victims recover money through the Commissioner's process, and whether scammers send victims elsewhere, as the trips to Wisconsin show some already do. As of 20 October 2026, New Jersey's ban bill S2141, passed by the state Senate 37 to 3 on 30 June 2026, sits in an Assembly committee, and Delaware's HB 441 has been in a Senate committee since 11 June 2026.

Minnesota's operators must have their machines out of public view by 31 December 2026. North Carolina's refund duty takes effect on 1 January 2027, the same date by which its Commissioner of Banks must adopt the procedure for deciding which kiosk transactions were fraud.

Sources

  1. FinCEN, Notice FIN-2025-NTC1 on the use of CVC kiosks for scam payments (4 August 2025) fincen.gov
  2. FinCEN, press release on Notice FIN-2025-NTC1 (4 August 2025) fincen.gov
  3. FBI IC3, I-051526-PSA: Cryptocurrency Kiosk Complaint Data by State (15 May 2026) ic3.gov
  4. District of Columbia v. Athena Bitcoin, Inc., complaint, D.C. Superior Court (8 September 2025) oag.dc.gov
  5. Office of the Attorney General for the District of Columbia, release (8 September 2025) oag.dc.gov
  6. Minnesota Statutes 2024, section 53B.75 revisor.mn.gov
  7. Minnesota Laws 2024, chapter 114, article 3 (definitions of new and existing customer) revisor.mn.gov
  8. Minnesota Department of Commerce, release on the 2024 crypto kiosk law (1 August 2024) mn.gov
  9. Minnesota Laws 2026, chapter 65 (S.F. 3868) revisor.mn.gov
  10. Minnesota House Session Daily, hearing on HF3642 (26 February 2026) house.mn.gov
  11. Minnesota Department of Commerce, release on the kiosk ban (14 May 2026) mn.gov
  12. Star Tribune, Minnesota bans cryptocurrency ATMs (May 2026) startribune.com
  13. Indiana House Enrolled Act 1116 (2026) iga.in.gov
  14. Orrick InfoBytes, Indiana signing (cross-check) infobytes.orrick.com
  15. Tennessee Public Chapter No. 766 (House Bill 2505) publications.tnsosfiles.com
  16. Orrick InfoBytes, Tennessee signing (cross-check) infobytes.orrick.com
  17. 8 V.S.A. § 2577, Virtual-currency kiosk prohibition legislature.vermont.gov
  18. Vermont General Assembly, H.648 (Act 142) status legislature.vermont.gov
  19. Vermont Department of Financial Regulation, Report on Virtual Currency Kiosks (15 January 2025) dfr.vermont.gov
  20. Vermont Act 23 of 2025 (as enacted; signed 19 May 2025), Sec. 24 amending 8 V.S.A. § 2577 legislature.vermont.gov
  21. Hawaii Act 224 (H.B. 1642 CD1), governor's message and act as signed (9 July 2026) data.capitol.hawaii.gov
  22. South Dakota Senate Bill 98 (2026), enrolled text mylrc.sdlegislature.gov
  23. AARP South Dakota, Governor Rhoden signs SB 98 (cross-check: signing and 1 July effective date) aarp.org
  24. North Carolina Session Law 2026-45 (House Bill 920) ncleg.gov
  25. ABC News, AUSTRAC crypto ATM limits (3 June 2025) abc.net.au
  26. Cointelegraph, Australia rolls out new crypto ATM rules (3 June 2025, cross-check) cointelegraph.com
  27. New Zealand Government, Crypto ATMs to get guardrails, not the guillotine (9 July 2026) beehive.govt.nz
  28. Bitcoin Depot Inc., Form 8-K (filed 18 May 2026) sec.gov
  29. Bitcoin Depot Inc., Exhibit 99.1 press release (18 May 2026) sec.gov
  30. New Jersey Legislature, S2141 (2026-2027 session) njleg.state.nj.us
  31. Delaware General Assembly, House Bill 441 legis.delaware.gov

Related stories

Explore

More articles