# Are Privacy Coins Illegal? What Privacy Is Left on a Public Blockchain

Published 2026-10-21 · Crypto.world Team · Crypto.world

> Holding Monero or Zcash in your own wallet is not what US or EU rules target. FinCEN dropped its mixer and unhosted-wallet proposals; from July 2027 the EU bars banks and crypto providers from accounts that allow anonymisation through privacy coins. What privacy is left.

## What a Public Ledger Reveals

Bitcoin's founding document gives a qualified answer on privacy. Section 10 of Satoshi Nakamoto's white paper says privacy can still be maintained "by keeping public keys anonymous", and concedes that "some linking is still unavoidable with multi-input transactions, which necessarily reveal that their inputs were owned by the same owner." Address clustering rests on that admission: group the addresses that spend together, then wait for one of them to meet a business that knows a name.

The business that knows a name is usually an exchange. A customer who buys coins on a regulated platform has undergone identity verification, and the withdrawal to a personal wallet is itself a public transaction. The first address in the chain therefore carries a name in the exchange's records, and every address clustered with it can inherit that name. Nothing on the ledger expires, so a later link reaches back to the first payment.

The Chairman of the US Securities and Exchange Commission described the result at the SEC Crypto Task Force's roundtable on financial surveillance and privacy on 15 December 2025, after noting that the views were his own and not necessarily those of the Commission:

> Public blockchains are more transparent than any legacy financial system ever built. Every movement of value is recorded on a ledger that anyone can inspect. Chain analytics firms are already exceptional at assisting law enforcement with linking on-chain activity to off-chain identities. In other words, pushed in the wrong direction, crypto could become the most powerful financial surveillance architecture ever invented. — Paul S. Atkins, Chairman, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission

By October 2026 the American and European rulebooks pointed in opposite directions. Washington withdrew two proposals that would have made banks and payment firms report mixing and unhosted-wallet transactions. Brussels has written a rule that, from 10 July 2027, closes regulated accounts to anonymity-enhancing coins.

Neither move changes the ledger, so the privacy that remains is what a person keeps in self-custody or proves selectively with zero-knowledge tools. Each of those tools discloses something to someone, and the regulated on-ramps decide which kinds of disclosure they accept back into the financial system.

:::callout-info **In one minute:** Bitcoin and Ethereum addresses are pseudonyms on a public ledger; an exchange's identity checks can attach a name to them. On 6 October 2026 FinCEN withdrew its 2023 mixer proposal and its 2020 unhosted-wallet proposal. A withdrawn proposal licenses nothing: sanctions and Bank Secrecy Act duties still apply. From 10 July 2027 the EU's Anti-Money Laundering Regulation forbids banks and crypto-asset service providers to keep accounts that allow anonymisation, including through anonymity-enhancing coins. It binds those firms, not people holding coins in their own wallets. Privacy Pools lets a user prove that a withdrawal comes from an approved deposit without revealing which one, but a company keeps the list of approved deposits. No EU authority has yet said whether a crypto-asset service provider may accept such a withdrawal once the EU rule applies. :::

## Washington Withdraws the Mixer and Unhosted-Wallet Proposals

On 6 October 2026 the Federal Register carried two notices from the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), both signed by its Deputy Director, Jimmy L. Kirby. FR Doc. 2026-20429 withdrew the section 311 finding that international mixing of convertible virtual currency (CVC) is "a class of transactions of primary money laundering concern", with the rule proposed on 23 October 2023 at 88 FR 72701. FR Doc. 2026-20430 withdrew the unhosted-wallet proposal of 23 December 2020 at 85 FR 83840.

Neither proposal would have banned holding a coin or using a mixer. The 2023 text defined mixing broadly, from pooling funds of several people to splitting transfers, single-use wallets and user-initiated delays, and would have made covered financial institutions report such transactions with wallet addresses, transaction hashes and IP addresses. The 2020 text would have made banks and money services businesses report transfers above $10,000 involving an unhosted wallet, or a wallet hosted in a jurisdiction FinCEN identified, and keep records above $3,000.

FinCEN's stated reason was its commenters' warning that the broad definition of mixing "could have a chilling effect on legitimate activity and place a large reporting burden on covered financial institutions." It also cited the July 2025 report of the President's Working Group on Digital Asset Markets.

FinCEN quotes that report as saying that "the Trump Administration supports the ability of lawful users of digital assets to privately transact on a public blockchain." The report's own sentence, on page 111 of the copy the White House published, is worded differently: "The Working Group supports civil liberties protections surrounding privacy and the ability of individuals to privately transact on public blockchains."

On page 107 the same report concedes both sides of the mixer question. Illicit actors, it says, "use mixers to obfuscate and launder funds", yet "lawful users of digital assets may leverage mixers to enable financial privacy when transacting through public blockchains." FinCEN kept a door open in its notice: it "will continue to monitor activity involving CVC mixers for indicia of money laundering, terrorist financing, or other illicit finance activity, and may take appropriate steps in the future to mitigate any such activity."

The shift had been framed in December 2025 at the SEC roundtable, where Commissioner Hester M. Peirce said: "Protecting one’s privacy should be the norm, not an indicator of criminal intent." She added that government "should resist the temptation to force intermediation for the purpose of creating a regulatory beachhead or facilitating financial surveillance." Whether the developers of such tools can be prosecuted, as in the cases brought against the founders of Tornado Cash and Samourai Wallet, is a question for the courts, covered in our essay on [whether writing mixer code is a crime](https://crypto.world/article/writing-code-money-transmission-tornado-cash-samourai).

## The EU Rule on Anonymity-Enhancing Coins From 10 July 2027

The EU's Anti-Money Laundering Regulation (AMLR), Regulation (EU) 2024/1624 of 31 May 2024, applies, under its Article 90, from 10 July 2027. Its Article 79(1) is the provision behind the common question of whether Monero is banned in Europe. It reads, in part, that "credit institutions, financial institutions and crypto-asset service providers shall be prohibited from keeping" anonymous crypto-asset accounts "as well as any account otherwise allowing for the anonymisation of the customer account holder or the anonymisation or increased obfuscation of transactions, including through anonymity-enhancing coins."

The regulation defines the term by function, with no list of coins and no threshold. Article 2(1), point (25), calls anonymity-enhancing coins "crypto-assets that have built-in features designed to make crypto-asset transfer information anonymous, either systematically or optionally." The last two words reach both designs on the market. Monero's project site says every Monero user "is anonymous by default"; Zcash's documentation describes shielded addresses alongside transparent ones, so its privacy is a choice.

The prohibition binds the firms Article 79 names: credit institutions, financial institutions and crypto-asset service providers (CASPs). Recital 160 adds that it "does not apply to providers of hardware and software or providers of self-hosted wallets insofar as they do not possess access to or control over those crypto-asset wallets." Article 79 says nothing about a person holding coins in a self-custodied wallet. The EU has not banned owning a privacy coin; it has barred regulated intermediaries from keeping accounts that allow anonymisation through one.

A narrower rule already applies to trading venues. Since 30 December 2024, Article 76(3) of the Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCA) has required a trading platform's operating rules to "prevent the admission to trading of crypto-assets that have an inbuilt anonymisation function unless the holders of those crypto-assets and their transaction history can be identified" by the CASP operating the platform.

Large exchanges moved before either date. Binance announced on 6 February 2024 that it would end trading on all its XMR pairs at 03:00 UTC on 20 February 2024. Kraken halted XMR trading and deposits for clients registered in the European Economic Area at 15:00 UTC on 31 October 2024, citing "regulatory changes".

The detail below the regulation comes from the supervisors. AMLA, the EU's new anti-money-laundering authority, lists the European Banking Authority's guidelines that still apply until its own instruments replace them. Among them, the EBA's Travel Rule Guidelines (EBA/GL/2024/11) tell providers to weigh "anonymity-enhancing techniques, products or services, including, but not limited to, mixers or tumblers, Internet Protocol (IP) anonymisers and stealth addresses" when assessing whether a transfer raises suspicion.

## Privacy Pools, Proofs of Innocence and Viewing Keys

The most worked-out alternative to hiding funds is to prove something about where they came from. In "Blockchain privacy and regulatory compliance: Towards a practical equilibrium", published in Blockchain: Research and Applications in March 2024, Vitalik Buterin, Jacob Illum, Matthias Nadler, Fabian Schär and Ameen Soleimani study a protocol called Privacy Pools.

A user publishes a zero-knowledge proof that the withdrawn funds belong to a chosen association set of deposits, without revealing which deposit is theirs. Honest users can prove membership in a set that excludes known illicit deposits; users who cannot are left outside, which the authors call a separating equilibrium.

> The proposal may be a first step towards a future where people could prove regulatory compliance without having to reveal their entire transaction history. — Vitalik Buterin, Jacob Illum, Matthias Nadler, Fabian Schär and Ameen Soleimani, authors, Blockchain: Research and Applications

The company 0xbow put the design on Ethereum mainnet in March 2025. Its documentation says the protocol uses an Association Set Provider (ASP) "to maintain a set of approved deposits, preventing potentially illicit funds from entering the system". A depositor whose funds are not approved keeps one exit, the ragequit, which the documentation calls "a safety mechanism that allows the original depositor to publicly withdraw their funds without needing ASP approval."

Both ends of the trip are public. The project's site says shielding "reveals your address, asset, and amount shielded", and that withdrawing is public too, though it carries no link to the original deposit. The pool hides only the connection between the two.

On 20 October 2026 0xbow announced Privacy Pools v2 on seven networks, adding private transfers, payment requests, swaps and yield. It said v1 had taken in "over $26M in deposits" (per 0xbow, as of 20 October 2026). The model is unchanged: "Only funds approved by the Association Set Provider operated by 0xbow can transact privately, and approval can be revoked".

Other designs make the same trade from a different angle. Railgun's Private Proofs of Innocence work as a blocklist rather than an allowlist: when tokens are shielded, its documentation says, "a ZK proof is automatically created that proves that the tokens are not a part of a pre-set list of interactions and wallets."

Zcash gives each shielded address a viewing key, which "allows any user in possession of it to view the balance and transaction data of the associated shielded address." Monero has view keys too. In October 2025 the Ethereum Foundation announced Kohaku, "a new reference implementation of a privacy-preserving wallet and an open-source wallet SDK".

## Open Questions for Selective Disclosure

Privacy Pools depends on whoever keeps the list. The paper imagined custom association sets built to properties "required by regulation or social consensus". In the deployed protocol the set that matters is run by one company, which screens each deposit and can revoke approval later. The ASP decides at its discretion, and a user it turns away can recover the money only through the public exit, without privacy.

A proof of innocence is also not privacy from whoever checks it. Viewing keys and selective disclosure move information from everyone to someone: an exchange, an auditor, a tax office, a counterparty. Atkins's own example of a good system, one where "a regulated platform can demonstrate that its users have been screened", still has somebody doing the screening. These tools replace showing everything to everyone with showing a chosen slice to a chosen party.

The EU text does not yet say where these tools sit. Article 79 bars accounts allowing "increased obfuscation of transactions". The EBA, answering consultation comments on its Travel Rule Guidelines, treats privacy-enhancing technologies (PETs) as a broad family and anonymity-enhancing ones (AETs) as "a subset of PETs that specifically focus on concealing or obfuscating a user’s identity online".

The EBA confines that guideline to AETs because they "present higher ML/TF risks". A pool that hides the link between deposit and withdrawal while proving clean provenance sits between those labels. No EU authority has said whether a CASP may accept a Privacy Pools withdrawal after 10 July 2027.

The American side leaves the same decision with the intermediary. The White House report that FinCEN cited also says that "regulated intermediaries need to be able to identify customers, report suspicious activities, and freeze or block certain transactions in line with their BSA and sanctions obligations." Withdrawing the mixer proposal dropped a proposed special reporting duty; it did not remove those general ones.

## Where the Rules Apply to a User in 2027

Holding is where both rulebooks are lightest. The EU's prohibition binds banks, financial institutions and CASPs, and expressly spares wallet makers without access to the wallets. The American proposals that FinCEN withdrew were reporting duties for banks, money services businesses and, in the 2023 mixer proposal, all covered financial institutions.

The rules bite at the on-ramp. In the EU, MiCA already keeps such coins off trading platforms unless holders and history can be identified, and from 10 July 2027 the AMLR closes CASP accounts that allow anonymisation through them. Moving coins between an exchange and your own wallet brings its own checks, set out in our essay on [the crypto Travel Rule](https://crypto.world/article/crypto-travel-rule-fatf-eu-transfer-of-funds).

In the United States the withdrawal is a policy choice, and a policy can be reversed: FinCEN said it "may take appropriate steps in the future". Sanctions remain the sharper tool. The Treasury's Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) designated the mixers Blender.io on 6 May 2022 and Sinbad on 29 November 2023. When the Treasury lifted its Tornado Cash sanctions on 21 March 2025, it called the step an exercise of "discretion" and warned that "U.S. persons should exercise caution before engaging in transactions that present such risks."

On 10 July 2027 Article 79 starts to apply, and by that same day AMLA must issue guidelines, under Article 40(2) of the AMLR, on the measures a CASP must take for transfers to and from self-hosted addresses, including how to verify whether such an address is owned or controlled by its customer.

## Sources

1. [FinCEN, Proposal of Special Measure Regarding CVC Mixing; Withdrawal, FR Doc. 2026-20429, 91 FR 63513 (6 October 2026)](https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/10/06/2026-20429/proposal-of-special-measure-regarding-convertible-virtual-currency-mixing-as-a-class-of-transactions) federalregister.gov
2. [FinCEN, Requirements for Certain Transactions Involving CVC or Digital Assets; Withdrawal, FR Doc. 2026-20430, 91 FR 63514 (6 October 2026)](https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/10/06/2026-20430/requirements-for-certain-transactions-involving-convertible-virtual-currency-or-digital-assets) federalregister.gov
3. [Regulation (EU) 2024/1624 (Anti-Money Laundering Regulation), OJ L, 19.6.2024: Articles 2, 40, 79, 90 and recital 160](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2024/1624/oj) eur-lex.europa.eu
4. [Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 (MiCA), Articles 76(3) and 149](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2023/1114/oj) eur-lex.europa.eu
5. [SEC, Paul S. Atkins, Remarks at the Crypto Task Force Roundtable on Financial Surveillance and Privacy (15 December 2025)](https://www.sec.gov/newsroom/speeches-statements/atkins-121525-remarks-crypto-task-force-roundtable-financial-surveillance-privacy) sec.gov
6. [SEC, Hester M. Peirce, Privacy in the House: Remarks at the Privacy and Financial Surveillance Roundtable (15 December 2025)](https://www.sec.gov/newsroom/speeches-statements/peirce-remarks-crypto-task-force-roundtable-121525) sec.gov
7. [President's Working Group on Digital Asset Markets, Strengthening American Leadership in Digital Financial Technology (July 2025), pp. 100, 107, 111](https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/Digital-Assets-Report-EO14178.pdf) whitehouse.gov
8. [European Banking Authority, Travel Rule Guidelines, EBA/GL/2024/11 (4 July 2024), para. 47 and feedback table](https://www.eba.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2024-07/6de6e9b9-0ed9-49cd-985d-c0834b5b4356/Travel%20Rule%20Guidelines.pdf) eba.europa.eu
9. [AMLA, Regulatory Instruments (EBA guidelines that continue to apply; last updated 7 October 2026)](https://www.amla.europa.eu/policy/regulatory-instruments_en) amla.europa.eu
10. [Buterin, Illum, Nadler, Schär, Soleimani, Blockchain privacy and regulatory compliance: Towards a practical equilibrium, Blockchain: Research and Applications 5(1), 100176 (2024)](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bcra.2023.100176) doi.org
11. [Privacy Pools Documentation (0xbow): overview, ASP layer, ragequit](https://docs.privacypools.com/) docs.privacypools.com
12. [Privacy Pools Documentation, Ragequit](https://docs.privacypools.com/protocol/ragequit) docs.privacypools.com
13. [0xbow, Privacy Pools v2 is live (20 October 2026)](https://0xbow.io/blog/privacy-pools-v2-is-live) 0xbow.io
14. [Privacy Pools (privacypools.com), FAQ: what stays private](https://privacypools.com/) privacypools.com
15. [Satoshi Nakamoto, Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System, section 10 (Privacy)](https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf) bitcoin.org
16. [Binance, Binance Will Delist ANT, MULTI, VAI, XMR on 2024-02-20 (6 February 2024)](https://www.binance.com/en/support/announcement/f73b083ba6834771b07dbe5319917ae5) binance.com
17. [Kraken Support, Support for Monero (XMR) in Europe](https://support.kraken.com/hc/en-us/articles/support-for-monero-xmr-in-europe) support.kraken.com
18. [U.S. Treasury, Tornado Cash Delisting (21 March 2025)](https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sb0057) home.treasury.gov
19. [U.S. Treasury, Treasury Sanctions Mixer Used by the DPRK to Launder Stolen Virtual Currency (29 November 2023)](https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/jy1933) home.treasury.gov
20. [RAILGUN Docs, Private Proofs of Innocence](https://docs.railgun.org/wiki/assurance/private-proofs-of-innocence) docs.railgun.org
21. [Zcash Documentation, Glossary (viewing key, shielded and transparent addresses)](https://zcash.readthedocs.io/en/latest/rtd_pages/glossary.html) zcash.readthedocs.io
22. [Monero Project, What is Monero](https://www.getmonero.org/get-started/what-is-monero/) getmonero.org
23. [Monero Project, Moneropedia: View Key](https://www.getmonero.org/resources/moneropedia/viewkey.html) getmonero.org
24. [Ethereum Foundation Blog, privacy commitment and Kohaku (8 October 2025)](https://blog.ethereum.org/en/2025/10/08/privacy-commitment) blog.ethereum.org

## Related stories

- [Is Writing Mixer Code a Crime? What the Tornado Cash Cases Settled](https://crypto.world/ethics/writing-code-money-transmission-tornado-cash-samourai)
- [Where the Scam Cashes Out: Why Warnings Failed at Crypto ATMs](https://crypto.world/ethics/crypto-atm-scams-warnings-bans-refunds)
- [The Crypto Travel Rule: What the EU Requires and Where It Breaks](https://crypto.world/ethics/crypto-travel-rule-fatf-eu-transfer-of-funds)

## Explore

[More articles](https://crypto.world/ethics)

---

Canonical: https://crypto.world/ethics/privacy-coins-mixers-public-blockchain-us-eu-rules
