# Is It Still Yours? How Exchanges Hold Your Crypto After FTX

Published 2026-10-20 · Crypto.world Team · Crypto.world

> Whether crypto on an exchange is still yours turns on three facts the filings show: whose wallets hold it, whether the contract makes you an owner or a creditor, and whether the platform may lend it. Proof of reserves cannot see the last two.

## Three Facts That Decide Whether Exchange Crypto Is Still Yours

"Is my crypto safe on an exchange?" depends less on how much the platform holds than on three facts written into its filings, user agreements and rulebooks. The first is whose name and which wallets hold the coins: segregated per customer, or pooled in an omnibus wallet. The second is whether the contract leaves the customer an owner or makes them an unsecured creditor. The third is whether the platform may lend or pledge the assets.

Proof-of-reserves snapshots, the transparency tool many exchanges adopted after FTX, answer a narrower question: did the platform control enough coins at one moment? By Kraken's own description of its method, and in the view of the US audit regulator's investor advocate, they cannot see loans, pledges or contract terms, the things at the centre of FTX, Celsius and Gemini's Earn program. And Coinbase's annual report for 2025 still tells investors that courts have not yet considered the legal treatment meant to keep its customers' crypto out of a bankruptcy estate.

**In one minute**

- Segregation: per-customer wallets, or omnibus wallets holding only customer coins and tracked on a ledger reconciled to the chain.
- Ownership: Celsius's Earn terms transferred title and a court enforced them; Coinbase and Gemini say customers own their coins, and Coinbase adds that no court has ruled on its approach.
- Lending: the sentence that matters is the exception, such as "without the customer's consent".
- Proof of reserves: a dated snapshot, not an audit, blind to borrowing and pledges.

## What FTX Promised in Writing, and What the Complaints Allege

FTX's Terms of Service, as quoted in the Securities and Exchange Commission's complaint against Samuel Bankman-Fried (No. 1:22-cv-10501, S.D.N.Y., filed 13 December 2022), said that "[t]itle to your Digital Assets shall at all times remain with you and shall not transfer to FTX". A document titled "FTX's Key Principles for Ensuring Investor Protections on Digital-Asset Platforms" said FTX "segregates customer assets from its own assets across our platforms."

The complaint alleges that customer money went elsewhere. From 2019 until at least 2021, according to the SEC, FTX customers sent dollars to bank accounts controlled by Alameda Research, Bankman-Fried's crypto hedge fund, some in the name of an Alameda subsidiary called North Dimension. The liability sat in an internal FTX account named "fiat@ftx.com", and Alameda's portion came to more than $8 billion of customer assets. The SEC also describes a "virtually unlimited" line of credit that let Alameda trade with other customers' deposits.

Those are a civil complaint's allegations. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission's complaint, filed the same day, describes the same North Dimension accounts and a "fiat@ftx" balance of as much as $8 billion. In the criminal case a jury convicted Bankman-Fried on seven counts on 2 November 2023, and on 28 March 2024 he was sentenced to 25 years in prison, according to the US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York.

A customer could not see whose bank account held the money or who could borrow against it. The wording of a promise proves little: FTX's title sentence reads almost word for word like the one in Coinbase's current US user agreement. Such promises differ in the legal and supervisory structure behind them, and that is what the filings describe.

## Owner or Unsecured Creditor: The Contract Decides First

The clearest ruling on ownership came from the Celsius bankruptcy. On 4 January 2023, Chief Judge Martin Glenn of the US Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York (Case No. 22-10964, ECF 1822) held that crypto deposited in Celsius's Earn accounts became Celsius's property, and that coins left there on the petition date belonged to the bankruptcy estates. About 600,000 Earn accounts held roughly $4.2 billion of crypto as of 10 July 2022, according to the opinion.

The reason was the contract. Version 8 of Celsius's Terms of Use granted the company "all right and title" to Earn deposits, "including ownership rights," and the right to "pledge, re-pledge, hypothecate, rehypothecate, sell, lend" them. The court applied those terms as written, leaving account holders with unsecured claims:

> But based on the unambiguous contract terms, subject to any reserved defenses, the Court finds and concludes that the cryptocurrency assets deposited in Earn Accounts are presumptively property of the estate and not property of the Account Holders. — Martin Glenn, Chief United States Bankruptcy Judge, Southern District of New York

Coinbase's annual report for 2025, filed on 12 February 2026, describes the same risk from the other side. Custodied crypto "may be considered to be the property of a bankruptcy estate," it says, and customers "could be treated as our general unsecured creditors." Its answer is Article 8 of the Uniform Commercial Code, the US law on securities held through intermediaries. In June 2022 Coinbase updated its Retail User Agreement to clarify that Article 8 applies to custodied crypto.

The filing stops short of calling the question settled. "In light of UCC Article 8, we believe that a court would not treat custodied crypto assets as part of our general estate; however, due to the novelty of crypto assets, courts have not yet considered this type of treatment for custodied crypto assets," it says. Gemini's annual report, filed on 31 March 2026, is hedged the same way: the company "believes that the cryptocurrency it holds in custody for users should be considered their property."

New York's Department of Financial Services sets the expectation. Its custody guidance, first issued on 23 January 2023 and replaced by an updated version on 30 September 2025, expects a custodian to take possession only for custody and safekeeping, so that it "will not thereby establish a debtor-creditor relationship with the customer." Being a creditor instead is slow: [Mt. Gox has moved its creditor repayment deadline to October 2027](https://crypto.world/news/mt-gox-repayment-deadline-october-2027).

## Segregated or Omnibus: Where the Coins Sit

The same guidance accepts two structures. Customer coins can sit in "separate on-chain wallets and internal ledger accounts for each customer under that customer's name". Or they can sit in omnibus wallets "that contain only virtual currency of customers held under the VCE Custodian's name as agent or trustee for the benefit of those customers." In an omnibus wallet the internal ledger is the only record of who owns which coin, so the regulator expects custodians to show reconciliation between books and chain whenever asked.

Coinbase uses both models. Its cold-storage custody entities, Coinbase Custody Trust Company and Coinbase Luxembourg S.A., hold crypto "separately in dedicated addresses"; Coinbase says the Luxembourg entity must use segregated cold storage under the EU's Markets in Crypto-Assets regulation (MiCA). Coinbase, Inc., the party to its US user agreement, holds crypto "in an omnibus manner on the blockchain and separately recorded using a ledger system."

Customer cash is a separate pool: $5.35 billion at 31 December 2025, held in segregated accounts "for the exclusive benefit of customers." Customer crypto is far larger. Coinbase reported $376 billion of Assets on Platform at the same date, its own measure of crypto and stablecoins held or managed for customers, at market value.

Gemini's filing describes pooled structures. Customer crypto sits "in one or more Gemini pooled digital wallets," each customer's interest recorded on Gemini's ledger, and users' cash sits with banks "in omnibus accounts." Gemini says it reconciles that ledger to on-chain balances monthly, under controls covered by its SOC 1 Type 2 examination.

The same filing reports a material weakness: controls "over the digital asset reconciliation between our internal ledger and the public blockchain" were "not effectively designed and implemented and, therefore, did not operate effectively." With pooled wallets, customers' coins are kept apart only on the ledger, so that reconciliation is what segregation rests on.

The EU writes a baseline into law. MiCA, Regulation (EU) 2023/1114, bars providers from using clients' crypto "for their own account" and requires client money to reach a credit institution or central bank by the end of the next business day, in a separately identifiable account (Article 70). Custodians keep a register of positions per client, and must hold client crypto apart from their own "on the distributed ledger", segregated "so that creditors of the crypto-asset service provider have no recourse" to it (Article 75).

## Lending and Pledging: The Exceptions in the Contract

The third fact usually sits in one sentence. Coinbase's annual report says: "We do not use customer assets as collateral for any loan, margin, rehypothecation, or other similar activities to which we or our affiliates are a party, without the customer's consent." Its user agreement says Coinbase will not "sell, transfer, loan, hypothecate, or otherwise alienate" a customer's assets except as required by law, "as instructed by you," or under a card that takes USDC as a deposit. The exceptions are where the customer's choices count.

New York's 2025 guidance draws the line for custody itself. A custodian "should not use customer virtual currency to secure or guarantee an obligation of, or extend credit to, the VCE Custodian or any other person except the customer," and credit products for customers need the department's prior approval. Under that wording, lending custodied coins to a third party is not part of custody at all.

Gemini Earn shows why. According to the Department of Financial Services, Earn launched on 1 February 2021 and let Gemini customers lend crypto to Genesis Global Capital, an unregulated third party that lent the same assets on. In November 2022 Genesis suspended redemptions after entities to which it had lent Earn customers' assets defaulted, and it filed for bankruptcy two months later. Under a consent order of 28 February 2024, Gemini Trust contributed $40.0 million to Earn users' recovery and paid a $37.0 million civil penalty, its annual report says.

The dispute has not closed. As of 30 July 2026, Gemini reported 376 arbitrations filed by Earn users seeking additional interest separate from their recovery in the Genesis bankruptcy. Its quarterly report, filed on 13 August 2026, says that of 15 bellwether cases Gemini has largely prevailed in the first five and is awaiting decisions in five more, and that the remaining five are expected to be tried before the end of 2026. At Celsius and at Earn alike, the coins left under terms the customer had accepted, and once lent, a coin was only a claim on whoever borrowed it.

## Proof of Reserves: A Dated Snapshot, Not an Audit

Kraken's proof-of-reserves page shows how the method works and where it stops. In October 2026 it showed a snapshot dated 30 June 2026, with reserve ratios of 102.9% for bitcoin and 100.5% for ether among eight assets. An independent accountant builds a Merkle tree from anonymised client balances, collects signatures proving Kraken controls the on-chain addresses, and checks that those holdings match or exceed client balances. The report linked from the page names The Network Firm LLP as attestation provider.

Kraken publishes the limits too. The procedure, it says, "cannot prove exclusive possession of private keys that may have theoretically been duplicated by an attacker." Under "Shortcomings and future improvements" it continues:

> The procedure cannot identify any hidden encumbrances or prove that funds had not been borrowed for purposes of passing the review. Similarly, keys may have been lost or funds stolen since the latest review. — Kraken, Proof of Reserves page, "Shortcomings and future improvements"

The investor advocate at the US audit regulator went further. In an advisory dated 8 March 2023, the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board's Office of the Investor Advocate wrote that "PoR engagements are not audits and, consequently, the related reports do not provide any meaningful assurance to investors or the public." The procedures likely do not address the entity's liabilities, "the rights and obligations of the digital asset holders," or whether assets were borrowed to make reserves look sufficient.

Each of the three failures falls outside those limits. FTX, as the complaints describe it, turned on a liability, customer money owed by an affiliate; Celsius on a contract that transferred title; Earn on a loan to a third party. Liabilities, holders' rights and borrowed assets are what the PCAOB and Kraken place outside a snapshot. A ratio above 100% says the coins were there on the day, not who else had a claim on them.

## Zondacrypto: A Cold Wallet the Exchange Says It Could Not Open

A 2026 case shows the reverse problem: coins counted but out of reach. On 17 April 2026 the Regional Prosecutor's Office in Katowice opened an investigation into Zondacrypto, the exchange formerly called BitBay, for fraud involving property of considerable value (Article 286 §1 with Article 294 §1 of the Polish Criminal Code) and money laundering (Article 299 §1 and §5). Damage was then estimated at "nie mniej niż 350 mln złotych", not less than 350 million zloty.

The prosecutors' communiqué reports the owner's statement that since 2022 the exchange "nie posiadała ona dostępu do tzw. zimnego portfela", had no access to the so-called cold wallet, said to hold about 4,500 BTC, and that clients were not told. A proof-of-reserves review of the kind Kraken describes asks an exchange to prove control of the addresses it counts by signing with their keys. By the owner's account, Zondacrypto could not have done that for its cold wallet since 2022.

All of it remains allegation and the owner's statement. By a decision of 30 July 2026 the case was merged into a National Prosecutor's Office investigation (file 1001-109.Ds.77.2022) that examines the founding and operation of BitBay in connection with the disappearance of Sylwester Suszek. Three people detained on 2 September 2026 were charged with offences including causing large-scale damage to the exchange's operator or misappropriating its money. A court remanded them for three months on 4 September; they did not admit the charges, prosecutors said.

The operator is an Estonian company. Estonia's Business Register lists BB Trade Estonia OÜ (registry code 14814864), registered on 30 September 2019, with the status "In bankruptcy". According to Poland's National Prosecutor's Office, the Harju County Court in Tallinn declared it bankrupt with effect from 27 August 2026 and Margus Lentsius was appointed trustee.

## Questions to Ask Before Leaving Crypto on a Platform

None of these questions yields a verdict on a platform; each can be answered from documents it publishes or files.

- **Which legal entity holds my assets, and where is it licensed?** Coinbase's filing names three entities that hold customer crypto; Zondacrypto's customers were dealing with a company in Tallinn.
- **What does my agreement say about title, and on what legal basis?** Look for a title clause, an Article 8 designation in the US or a MiCA-authorised entity in the EU, and for whether a court has tested it.
- **Segregated or omnibus?** If omnibus, how often is the ledger reconciled to the chain, and does the annual report disclose any weakness in those controls?
- **When may the platform lend, pledge or transfer my assets?** Read the exceptions, and check whether a product I opted into, such as lending, margin or a card that takes a deposit, counts as consent.
- **What does the proof of reserves cover?** Which assets, which date, which provider, and whether liabilities were examined at all.
- **Is anything insured, and by whom?** Coinbase states that crypto assets "are not insured or guaranteed by any government or government agency"; private policies, like the one [AnchorWatch attached to its bitcoin custody](https://crypto.world/news/anchorwatch-bitcoin-custody-370m-insurance), are contracts with their own terms.

The Zondacrypto bankruptcy shows what the creditor's position means in practice. Poland's National Prosecutor's Office has told victims that a criminal complaint and victim status do not replace a claim in the Estonian proceedings. Claims go to the trustee, directly or through a representative, and the deadline is 27 October 2026.

## Sources

1. [SEC v. Bankman-Fried, Complaint, No. 1:22-cv-10501 (S.D.N.Y., 13 December 2022)](https://www.sec.gov/files/litigation/complaints/2022/comp-pr2022-219.pdf) sec.gov
2. [CFTC v. Bankman-Fried, FTX Trading and Alameda Research, Complaint (S.D.N.Y., 13 December 2022)](https://www.cftc.gov/media/7986/enfftxtradingcomplaint121322/download) cftc.gov
3. [US Attorney's Office, Southern District of New York: Samuel Bankman-Fried Sentenced to 25 Years in Prison (28 March 2024)](https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/pr/samuel-bankman-fried-sentenced-25-years-prison) justice.gov
4. [In re Celsius Network LLC, No. 22-10964 (MG), ECF 1822: Memorandum Opinion and Order Regarding Ownership of Earn Account Assets (Bankr. S.D.N.Y., 4 January 2023)](https://www.nysb.uscourts.gov/sites/default/files/opinions/312902_1822_opinion.pdf) nysb.uscourts.gov
5. [GovInfo copy of the Celsius Earn ownership opinion (ECF 1822)](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-nysb-1_22-bk-10964/pdf/USCOURTS-nysb-1_22-bk-10964-7.pdf) govinfo.gov
6. [Coinbase Global, Inc., Annual Report on Form 10-K for fiscal 2025 (filed 12 February 2026)](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1679788/000167978826000015/coin-20251231.htm) sec.gov
7. [Coinbase, Individual User Agreement (United States), sections 2.7.1-2.7.2 (last updated 22 July 2026)](https://www.coinbase.com/legal/user_agreement/united_states) coinbase.com
8. [Gemini Space Station, Inc., Annual Report on Form 10-K for fiscal 2025 (filed 31 March 2026)](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2055592/000205559226000026/gemi-20251231.htm) sec.gov
9. [NYDFS Industry Letter: Updated Guidance on Custodial Structures for Customer Protection in the Event of Insolvency (30 September 2025)](https://www.dfs.ny.gov/industry-guidance/industry-letters/il20250930-updated-guidance-custodial-structures) dfs.ny.gov
10. [NYDFS Industry Letter: Guidance on Custodial Structures for Customer Protection in the Event of Insolvency (23 January 2023, superseded)](https://www.dfs.ny.gov/industry_guidance/industry_letters/il20230123_guidance_custodial_structures) dfs.ny.gov
11. [NYDFS press release: Gemini Trust Company commitment to Earn customers and $37 million penalty (28 February 2024)](https://www.dfs.ny.gov/reports_and_publications/press_releases/pr202402282) dfs.ny.gov
12. [Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 on markets in crypto-assets (MiCA), Articles 70 and 75](https://publications.europa.eu/resource/celex/32023R1114) publications.europa.eu
13. [Kraken, Proof of Reserves page (snapshot of 30 June 2026; read 20 October 2026)](https://www.kraken.com/proof-of-reserves) kraken.com
14. [Kraken Proof of Reserves summary report, attestation provider The Network Firm LLP (snapshot 30 June 2026)](https://widget.pro.ledgerlens.io/kraken-platform-spot-futures) widget.pro.ledgerlens.io
15. [PCAOB Office of the Investor Advocate, Investor Advisory: Exercise Caution With Third-Party Verification/Proof of Reserve Reports (8 March 2023)](https://pcaobus.org/resources/information-for-investors/investor-advisories/investor-advisory-exercise-caution-with-third-party-verification-proof-of-reserve-reports) pcaobus.org
16. [Prokuratura Regionalna w Katowicach: Śledztwo w sprawie Zondacrypto (17 April 2026)](https://www.gov.pl/web/pr-katowice/sledztwo-w-sprawie-zondacrypto) gov.pl
17. [Prokuratura Regionalna w Katowicach: ZondaCrypto, aktualizacja 4.0 (3 August 2026)](https://www.gov.pl/web/pr-katowice/zondacrypto--aktualizacja-40) gov.pl
18. [Prokuratura Krajowa: Statement of the Prosecutor General on the ZondaCrypto investigation (25 August 2026)](https://www.gov.pl/web/prokuratura-krajowa/zondacrypto-oswiadczenie) gov.pl
19. [Prokuratura Krajowa: Detention requests for three people in the ZondaCrypto case (3-4 September 2026)](https://www.gov.pl/web/prokuratura-krajowa/wnioski-o-tymczasowe-aresztowanie-wobec-kolejnych-3-osob-w-sprawie-zondacrypto) gov.pl
20. [Prokuratura Krajowa: Notice to victims on the bankruptcy of ZondaCrypto's operator (15 September 2026)](https://www.gov.pl/web/prokuratura-krajowa/komunikat-dla-pokrzywdzonych-w-zwiazku-z-ogloszeniem-upadlosci-operatora-gieldy-zondacrypto) gov.pl
21. [Estonian e-Business Register: BB Trade Estonia OÜ (14814864)](https://ariregister.rik.ee/eng/company/14814864/BB-Trade-Estonia-O%C3%9C) ariregister.rik.ee
22. [Notes from Poland: Polish prosecutors identify hundreds of possible victims of troubled crypto platform (21 April 2026), cross-check](https://notesfrompoland.com/2026/04/21/polish-prosecutors-identify-hundreds-of-possible-victims-of-troubled-crypto-platform/) notesfrompoland.com
23. [OPB/NPR: Sam Bankman-Fried sentenced to 25 years in prison for his FTX crimes (28 March 2024), cross-check](https://www.opb.org/article/2024/03/28/sam-bankman-fried-sentenced-to-25-years-in-prison-for-his-ftx-crimes/) opb.org
24. [Gemini Space Station, Inc., Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the quarter ended 30 June 2026 (filed 13 August 2026)](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2055592/000205559226000065/gemi-20260630.htm) sec.gov

## Companies in this story

- [Coinbase](https://crypto.world/companies/coinbase)

## Related stories

- [Is Base Decentralized? Ethereum's Blobs, Rollup Stages, Sequencers](https://crypto.world/industries/ethereum-blobs-rollup-stages-sequencer-outages)
- [Is Bitcoin Mining Still Profitable? What Miners' Filings Show](https://crypto.world/industries/bitcoin-miners-halving-ai-data-center-leases)
- [Aave Liquidations Under Stress: Where DeFi Lending Actually Broke](https://crypto.world/industries/defi-lending-liquidations-oracles-curators)

## Explore

[More articles](https://crypto.world/industries)

---

Canonical: https://crypto.world/industries/crypto-exchange-custody-segregation-proof-of-reserves-after-ftx
