# Can Stablecoins Pay Interest? The Fight Is Over Who Keeps the Float

Published 2026-10-21 · Crypto.world Team · Crypto.world

> The GENIUS Act bars stablecoin issuers from paying interest, but reserves still earn Treasury-bill income. Circle's, Coinbase's and Tether's own figures show where that money goes, and why the rewards fight is about who owns the customer.

## The Ban in Section 4(a)(11) and When It Applies

Under the GENIUS Act a stablecoin issuer may not pay its holders interest; an exchange that holds the coins for them can, and Coinbase does. The Act bans issuer payments of "any form of interest or yield", but a fiat-backed coin still earns Treasury-bill income on its reserves, and the ban steers that income toward whoever owns the customer. Read through the companies' own filings, the rewards fight that helped stall the Senate's market-structure bill is a fight over who keeps that float.

**In one minute**

- The ban in Section 4(a)(11) of the GENIUS Act binds issuers, not the platforms that hold coins for their users.
- Reserves still earn: Circle booked $668 million of reserve income in the second quarter of 2026.
- Most of it went out again: $412 million in distribution, transaction and other costs, $324.6 million of it under Circle's agreements with Coinbase.
- In the same quarter Coinbase recorded $119.1 million of USDC rewards, an expense that grows with customer balances.
- Tether, which publishes no distribution line, reported about $1.50 billion of net operating profit for the quarter; the change-in-net-equity table of its 30 June reserves report shows a half-year financial result of minus $3.17 billion.
- The Act takes effect on 18 January 2027 at the latest.

The rule sits in Public Law 119-27, signed on 18 July 2025. Its paragraph on interest is one sentence long:

> No permitted payment stablecoin issuer or foreign payment stablecoin issuer shall pay the holder of any payment stablecoin any form of interest or yield (whether in cash, tokens, or other consideration) solely in connection with the holding, use, or retention of such payment stablecoin. — GENIUS Act, Public Law 119-27, Section 4(a)(11)

"Issuer" names who is bound, and "solely" leaves room for payments tied to something other than holding the coin. The paragraph says nothing about the exchanges, wallets and brokers that hold coins on behalf of their users. The White House Council of Economic Advisers (CEA) read it the same way in April 2026: the Act prohibits issuers from offering yield "but does not explicitly prohibit affiliate or third-party arrangements that might offer interest-bearing products".

Section 20 sets the start date: the earlier of 18 months after enactment, which is 18 January 2027, or 120 days after the primary federal stablecoin regulators issue final regulations. Those regulators are the OCC, the Federal Reserve, the FDIC and the NCUA. None had a final GENIUS rule in the Federal Register by 20 October 2026, and 120 days from that date falls in February 2027. The long-stop therefore applies, as Treasury's own proposal anticipates: the effective date "is expected to be January 18, 2027".

That Treasury proposal, Federal Register document 2026-16796 published on 18 August 2026, implements Section 3: who may issue, offer and sell payment stablecoins in the United States. Its comment period closed on 19 October 2026, as industry groups pressed Treasury to [narrow its GENIUS Act rules](https://crypto.world/news/blockchain-association-treasury-genius-act-rules). It does not touch the yield ban.

The bank regulators have taken it up. The OCC's proposal of 2 March 2026 would have presumed that an issuer pays prohibited yield when it pays an affiliate or a "related third party" that in turn pays holders. Related third parties were firms paying yield to holders "as a service" on the issuer's behalf, and white-label partners; other arrangements the OCC would have assessed "on a case-by-case basis". The OCC's final rule, published in the Federal Register on 23 October 2026, eliminates that presumption and provides no general safe harbour, so whether a distributor paying rewards out of its own revenue falls inside the prohibition turns on the facts: any such arrangement "can be evaluated based on all relevant facts and circumstances".

## Where the Money Comes From: Reserve Income at 3.5%

A dollar stablecoin is a liability backed by assets that pay interest. The GENIUS Act limits those reserves to cash, deposits at insured banks, Treasuries with 93 days or less to maturity, overnight repurchase agreements, government money market funds and a few close equivalents. The holder gets a token redeemable for a dollar, and the issuer gets the interest on the dollar.

In the second quarter of 2026 Circle reported $701 million of total revenue and reserve income, of which $668 million was reserve income, on an average of $76.5 billion of USDC in circulation; $73.3 billion was outstanding on 30 June. Its reserve return rate was 3.5%, down 66 basis points from a year earlier. Circle's 10-Q puts the decline down to "interest rate actions undertaken by the U.S. Federal Reserve".

According to the same 10-Q, about 84% of the reserves sat in the Circle Reserve Fund, a government money market fund managed by BlackRock, and the rest in cash at banks. Circle names two inputs to reserve income: the reserve return rate and, primarily, the amount of USDC in circulation. Neither is set by the holder, who under the Act may receive none of the result from the issuer.

Circle is one issuer among several. DefiLlama's on-chain series counted about $304.6 billion of dollar-pegged stablecoins on 19 October 2026. Wherever such coins are backed by Treasury bills and bank cash, the reserves earn, and the policy question is where that income ends up.

## Where the Money Goes: Circle's Distribution Bill

Circle does not keep most of what its reserves earn. In the second quarter of 2026 it booked $412 million of distribution, transaction and other costs, leaving $289 million of what it calls revenue less distribution costs (RLDC). Its RLDC margin, that figure as a share of total revenue and reserve income, was 41%, up 302 basis points from a year earlier. Net income from continuing operations was $48 million.

Most of the bill goes to Coinbase. Circle's 10-Q says it incurred $324.6 million of distribution costs "in connection with our agreements with Coinbase" in the quarter, against $332.3 million a year earlier.

Under the Collaboration Agreement of 18 August 2023, Circle retains an issuer portion of net reserve income, each party is allocated income on the USDC held on its own platform, and Coinbase receives half of what remains from coins circulating elsewhere, after payments to approved third-party participants. Coinbase also received a minority equity stake in Circle in 2023, and a licence to use certain Circle trademarks, USDC among them, in marketing and distributing the coins.

Circle's annual report gives the agreement an initial three-year term. If the two companies do not agree on changes, it renews automatically for further three-year terms unless either fails to meet its obligations. The initial term ran out in August 2026 and the agreement rolled over: on Circle's results call of 5 August 2026, chief executive Jeremy Allaire said that "our agreement with Coinbase has renewed on its existing terms".

Circle's own interest-rate model shows how closely the two lines move together. Holding USDC in circulation at its 30 June level, a 100-basis-point change in rates would move Circle's reserve income by $737 million over twelve months and its distribution and transaction costs by $360 million. Roughly half of every dollar the reserves gain or lose, on that model, passes through to distribution.

How the income is split depends on where the coins are held. USDC on Circle's own platform reached $12.4 billion at quarter end, up 106% in a year. Circle attributes a $7.7 million fall in its payments to Coinbase to "a decrease in Coinbase's share of the total average USDC on-platform balances". Under a contract that allocates income by platform holdings, Circle keeps more when more coins sit in accounts it controls.

Coinbase's 10-Q for the same quarter shows the other side of the ledger. It booked $292.1 million of stablecoin revenue, against $308.9 million a year earlier as restated. The restatement moved $23.6 million earned on Coinbase's own corporate stablecoin balances into a separate line, with, in Coinbase's words, "no change to the Company's arrangement with Circle Internet Financial, LLC or the revenue generated." Coinbase attributes the decline to lower average interest rates, partly offset by higher USDC balances held by customers in eligible Coinbase products.

Its annual report describes what Coinbase is paid for:

> Pursuant to the Circle Agreement, Circle is the issuer of USDC, holds the relevant trademarks which we can use, and pays us for our role in the growth of USDC: the greater the proportion of USDC in circulation generally and on our platform, the greater our revenue generated under the Circle Agreement. — Coinbase Global, Inc., Annual Report on Form 10-K for 2025

The same 10-Q carries a second line. Under sales and marketing, Coinbase recorded $119.1 million of USDC rewards in the quarter, up from $102.5 million. It ties the change to "growth in average customer USDC balances held in Coinbase products", partly offset by a lower rewards rate. The filing does not say that one line pays for the other. Read side by side, both rise with the same customer balances, and the rewards line equalled about 41% of the stablecoin revenue line.

## Tether's Figures for the Same Quarter

Circle's slim bottom line owes more to its distribution contract than to the business of issuing. Tether, the largest issuer, publishes no income statement and no distribution line, so what it pays anyone to circulate USD₮ cannot be read from its documents. It does publish a headline figure: with its attestation for the second quarter of 2026, prepared by BDO, Tether said on 31 July that its net operating profit, "led by U.S. Treasury and repo", reached approximately $1.50 billion.

The same release put USD₮ in issue at about $184.6 billion at the end of June, with reserves exceeding liabilities by about $4.11 billion. Circle had $289 million left after distribution on an average float of $76.5 billion, about 0.38% of the float in the quarter, before paying any of its $254 million of operating expenses. Tether's reported net operating profit equals about 0.81% of its end-June float.

The two figures are not defined alike. Tether's reserves include gold, bitcoin and secured loans that Circle's do not, and its net operating profit is Tether's own measure, taken from its release. The attested report published with that release shows a different bottom line for the half-year: a financial result of minus $3.17 billion between 31 December 2025 and 30 June 2026, which, with $943 million of net capital movements, took Tether's equity from $6.34 billion to $4.11 billion. The comparison does not prove that Tether pays nothing for distribution.

The operating figures do show that an issuer of a dollar stablecoin can keep a wide margin, and that Circle's thin one is what remains after its distribution bill. The ban reaches Tether's kind of issuer too: Section 4(a)(11) names foreign payment stablecoin issuers alongside permitted ones.

## Banks, Rewards and the Senate Vote

The banks' case is that rewards paid by platforms reopen the door the Act closed. The Independent Community Bankers of America (ICBA) wrote in a July 2026 legislative update that the prohibition "can be evaded by paying yield equivalents to stablecoin holders through crypto exchanges, affiliates, and other market participants". Its own modelling projects a $1.3 trillion reduction of the $4.8 trillion in community bank deposits, which it says could mean an $850 billion decline in lending.

On 13 July 2026 the American Bankers Association, ICBA and 76 state associations wrote to Senate leaders John Thune and Charles Schumer about Section 404 of the Clarity Act, its clause on interest and yield. The text they quoted barred covered parties from paying interest or yield "solely in connection with the holding" of a recipient's payment stablecoins. It also let permitted rewards be "calculated by reference to a balance, duration, tenure, or any combination of the foregoing". They asked for "solely" to be struck and the balance clause removed:

> Retaining this section would negate the goals of the upfront prohibition (to deter deposit flight) while tying rewards directly to how much and for how long customers hold payment stablecoins in wallets or exchanges. — American Bankers Association, Independent Community Bankers of America and 76 state associations, letter to Senate leaders, 13 July 2026

The administration's economists reached a different order of magnitude. At baseline, the CEA's model found that eliminating stablecoin yield would raise bank lending by $2.1 billion, or 0.02%, at a net welfare cost of $800 million per year; community banks would account for about $500 million of the extra lending. Even "stacking every worst-case assumption", the model produced $531 billion, a 4.4% increase in bank loans, under conditions the CEA called implausible. Its summary: "a yield prohibition would do very little to protect bank lending".

ICBA prices the deposits that could leave if yield is allowed and the market grows; the CEA prices the lending a ban would add. Neither measures what the filings show directly: hundreds of millions of dollars a quarter already flowing from reserves to distributors.

On 15 September 2026 the Senate voted 49 to 50 on cloture on the motion to proceed to the bill, H.R. 3633, short of the three-fifths required (roll call 234). Republicans Susan Collins, Josh Hawley, Jerry Moran and Thom Tillis voted no; Democrat Chris Coons did not vote. The Daily Caller reported that Tillis switched his vote so the bill could return on a motion to reconsider, and tied the failure to an unresolved ethics provision as well.

Hawley had explained his position in August. "I'm going to vote with my state on this," he told Politico, adding that people there were "very, very worried about the effect on community banks". As of 20 October 2026, the Senate's vote record for the year shows no further roll call on the bill.

## Who Keeps the Float After January 2027

The filings set out a chain the floor debate left out. A customer holding USDC on Coinbase in the second quarter of 2026 sat at the end of it: reserves earned $668 million, Circle incurred $410.4 million in distribution and transaction costs, $324.6 million of it to Coinbase, and Coinbase recorded $119.1 million of USDC rewards. Once in force, the issuer-interest ban leaves that pool as it is and settles who may hand it out.

The OCC's final rule of 23 October 2026 dropped the presumption it had proposed, under which yield an issuer routes through affiliates or white-label partners would have been presumed to be issuer interest unless the issuer rebutted it; it kept the power to judge any such arrangement on "all relevant facts and circumstances", and said rewards programs that predate the Act "will be evaluated the same" as newer ones. A Clarity Act amended as the banks asked would strip out the clause allowing rewards calculated by balance. Without an amended Clarity Act, the rewards in Coinbase's 10-Q sit outside the Act's text, on the CEA's reading.

Under any of these outcomes the reserve income still exists, and on the filings' evidence the largest share follows whoever controls the account in which the coin sits. As USDC on Circle's own platform more than doubled to $12.4 billion, its payments to Coinbase fell and its RLDC margin rose to 41%.

An issuer with no disclosed revenue-sharing contract reported $1.50 billion of net operating profit in a quarter; one that rents its distribution passes roughly half of every rate move onward. Banks argue for the float to stay in deposits, Coinbase pays part of it out as rewards, and Circle has been moving coins onto its own platform.

The Federal Reserve's GENIUS proposal, published on 29 September 2026, takes comments until 30 November 2026; the OCC's closed on 1 May and its final rule was published on 23 October 2026. Whatever the Federal Reserve's final rule says about rewards, the GENIUS Act's ban on issuer interest applies from 18 January 2027 at the latest.

## Sources

1. [GENIUS Act, Public Law 119-27 (GovInfo)](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/PLAW-119publ27/html/PLAW-119publ27.htm) govinfo.gov
2. [Treasury, GENIUS Act Regulations on Payment Stablecoin Issuance, Offer, and Sale (NPRM, 91 FR 53368, 18 August 2026)](https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/08/18/2026-16796/genius-act-regulations-on-payment-stablecoin-issuance-offer-and-sale) federalregister.gov
3. [OCC, Implementing the GENIUS Act for the Issuance of Stablecoins (NPRM, 91 FR 10202, 2 March 2026)](https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/03/02/2026-04089/implementing-the-guiding-and-establishing-national-innovation-for-us-stablecoins-act-for-the) federalregister.gov
4. [Federal Reserve Board, Implementing the Board's Responsibilities Under the GENIUS Act (NPRM, 91 FR 61580, 29 September 2026)](https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2026/09/29/2026-19860/implementing-the-federal-reserve-boards-responsibilities-under-the-genius-act) federalregister.gov
5. [Circle, Second Quarter 2026 Results (5 August 2026)](https://s206.q4cdn.com/265218871/files/doc_news/2026/Aug/05/CIRCLE_Q2-2026.pdf) s206.q4cdn.com
6. [Circle Internet Group, Form 10-Q for the quarter ended 30 June 2026](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1876042/000187604226000248/crcl-20260630.htm) sec.gov
7. [Circle Internet Group, Form 10-K for 2025](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1876042/000187604226000062/crcl-20251231.htm) sec.gov
8. [Circle Internet Group, Q2 2026 earnings call transcript (5 August 2026, MarketBeat)](https://www.marketbeat.com/earnings/reports/2026-8-5-circle-internet-group-inc-stock/) marketbeat.com
9. [Coinbase Global, Form 10-Q for the quarter ended 30 June 2026](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/0001679788/000167978826000088/coin-20260630.htm) sec.gov
10. [Coinbase Global, Form 10-K for 2025](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1679788/000167978826000015/coin-20251231.htm) sec.gov
11. [Tether, Q2 2026 attestation release (31 July 2026)](https://tether.io/news/tether-posts-strong-q2-performance-generates-1-5b-net-operating-profit-maintains-4-11b-reserve-buffer-and-expands-gold-holdings-to-more-than-146-tons/) tether.io
12. [Tether International, Financial Figures and Reserves Report as of 30 June 2026 (BDO opinion)](https://assets.ctfassets.net/vyse88cgwfbl/2kYf7r64h3tzwiu6F0CbUB/2997abd2f11ecea74a21528048b50707/Opinion___Report_-_Tether_International_Financial_Figure_30-06-2026.pdf) assets.ctfassets.net
13. [Council of Economic Advisers, Effects of Stablecoin Yield Prohibition on Bank Lending (8 April 2026)](https://www.whitehouse.gov/research/2026/04/effects-of-stablecoin-yield-prohibition-on-bank-lending/) whitehouse.gov
14. [ICBA, Legislative Update: Stablecoins (July 2026)](https://www.icba.org/documents/d/asset-library-45247/legislative-update-stablecoins-july-2026-) icba.org
15. [ABA, ICBA and state associations, joint letter to Senate leaders on the Clarity Act (13 July 2026)](https://www.aba.com/-/media/documents/letters-to-congress-and-regulators/jointltrclarity20260713.pdf) aba.com
16. [ABA Banking Journal, ABA, ICBA join state associations on Clarity Act yield provisions (13 July 2026)](https://bankingjournal.aba.com/2026/07/aba-icba-join-state-associations-in-urging-senate-to-strengthen-stablecoin-yield-provisions-in-clarity-act/) bankingjournal.aba.com
17. [U.S. Senate, Roll Call Vote 234 (119th Congress, 2nd Session)](https://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_votes/vote1192/vote_119_2_00234.htm) senate.gov
18. [U.S. Senate, Roll Call Votes, 119th Congress, 2nd Session](https://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_lists/vote_menu_119_2.htm) senate.gov
19. [Daily Caller, Major Crypto Bill Crumbles In Senate (15 September 2026)](https://dailycaller.com/2026/09/15/clarity-act-procedural-vote-senate/) dailycaller.com
20. [CoinGape, GOP Senator Josh Hawley Opposes Clarity Act Vote Over Community Bank Fears (6 August 2026)](https://coingape.com/clarity-act-update-republican-hawley-plans-no-vote-on-crypto-bill-brian-armstrong-responds/) coingape.com
21. [DefiLlama, total stablecoin circulating series (on-chain data, value for 19 October 2026)](https://stablecoins.llama.fi/stablecoincharts/all) stablecoins.llama.fi

## Companies in this story

- [Tether](https://crypto.world/companies/tether)

## Related stories

- [Is Base Decentralized? Ethereum's Blobs, Rollup Stages, Sequencers](https://crypto.world/industries/ethereum-blobs-rollup-stages-sequencer-outages)
- [Is Bitcoin Mining Still Profitable? What Miners' Filings Show](https://crypto.world/industries/bitcoin-miners-halving-ai-data-center-leases)
- [Aave Liquidations Under Stress: Where DeFi Lending Actually Broke](https://crypto.world/industries/defi-lending-liquidations-oracles-curators)

## Explore

[More articles](https://crypto.world/industries)

---

Canonical: https://crypto.world/industries/stablecoin-yield-ban-who-keeps-the-float
