Skip to content
Crypto.world

The Ledger

16,000 Chinese Victims Win Right to Appeal $5B Bitcoin Ruling

About 16,000 Chinese victims have won permission to appeal a UK ruling that Chinese law governs claims to more than 60,000 seized bitcoin. The coins are valued at about $5 billion, and the appeal could affect whether claimants seek repayment or rights to the bitcoin’s appreciation.

16,000 Chinese Victims Win Right to Appeal $5B Bitcoin Ruling

“The Applicants parted with their money in China.”

Mr Justice Turner, in his Oct. 12 ruling

About 16,000 Chinese victims have won permission to appeal a UK High Court ruling that Chinese law governs their claims to more than 60,000 bitcoin seized in Britain. The court granted permission on Friday, Oct. 16, four days after the ruling, Caixin Global reported. The decision opens a route to challenge the legal framework; it does not overturn the ruling or award the claimants any bitcoin.

The appeal challenges which law governs ownership

The dispute turns on whether claimants can establish rights to the bitcoin itself, including its rise in value, or whether their claims are limited to repayment under Chinese law. Caixin valued the seized coins at about 34 billion yuan, or $5 billion, roughly 200 times the 2014 purchase price cited in its report. The value at stake reflects bitcoin’s appreciation, but that increase does not establish that the claimants own the coins.

In a judgment dated Oct. 12, Mr Justice Turner ruled that Chinese law governs the underlying rights asserted by the victims. The High Court judgment says the fraud schemes were carried out in China, where investors made payments and the proceeds were converted into bitcoin. The judge’s ruling resolved the choice-of-law question, not whether individual claimants hold a property interest.

Permission to appeal is not a recovery order

The claims were brought under section 281 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, which allows a person who says recoverable property belongs to them to seek a declaration from the court. Turner wrote that applicants must show a proprietary interest; a claim that a perpetrator owes them money as a creditor is not enough. The judgment also states that the content of Chinese law and the evidence supporting each individual claim had not yet been determined.

That distinction leaves key questions open. The High Court has not decided whether Chinese law gives any claimant rights in the seized bitcoin, how much any successful claimant could recover, or whether a payment would include the coins’ appreciation. The appeal seeks to challenge the prior ruling that selected Chinese law, rather than settle those issues now.

A separate Chinese confiscation effort continues

Chinese prosecutors are separately seeking confiscation of assets connected to the case, Caixin reported. A Chinese confiscation order would not automatically decide claims in the UK proceedings, where the bitcoin remains subject to British court process. The two legal tracks therefore add uncertainty over who may ultimately control or benefit from the assets.

For the 16,000 claimants, the immediate result is procedural: they have permission to contest the choice-of-law ruling. The Oct. 12 judgment says any later assessment of their underlying property rights must take account of Chinese law, while the High Court’s next task is to determine what those rights mean for the bitcoin held in Britain.

Sources

  1. Original source Caixin Global caixinglobal.com

Other pages read

  1. The National Archives, Find Case Law caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk

Related stories

Explore

More articles