# Aave, Kamino and Veda Press SEC on DeFi Lending Rules

Published 2026-11-04 · Crypto.world Team · Crypto.world

> Veda, Aave Labs and Kamino Foundation say they submitted a legal framework to the SEC on October 26, 2026, and published a public summary on November 3. The framework argues that securities analysis should follow the rights, obligations and powers created by decentralized lending protocols and non-custodial vaults.

> “Our central argument is that securities regulation should follow the substance of the arrangement: who owns the assets, who assumes obligations, who exercises authority, and whose economic fortunes are at stake.”
>
> Team Veda, authors of the framework

Veda, [Aave Labs](https://crypto.world/companies/aave-labs) and Kamino Foundation say they submitted a detailed legal framework to the Securities and Exchange Commission on October 26, 2026, and requested engagement with SEC staff. The organizations published a public summary on November 3, the same day Veda posted an account of the proposal.

The organizations argue that securities analysis of decentralized lending protocols and non-custodial vaults should turn on the rights and powers the arrangements actually create. They say their submission applies existing law, rather than seeking a DeFi exemption, safe harbor or separate regulatory regime.

## Four securities-law tests, one focus on control

The framework examines the investment-contract test under Howey, the treatment of notes under Reves, the Investment Company Act of 1940 and the Investment Advisers Act of 1940. Its authors conclude that the protocol and vault arrangements they describe are not investment contracts or notes, that the described vaults are not investment companies, and that paid investment discretion does not by itself establish custody of client assets.

For decentralized lending, the argument centers on how users supply assets to smart contracts and receive interest calculated under published formulas. The paper says those features do not necessarily create a shared enterprise: users may share infrastructure and a rate without investing in a common business or venture. Its analysis of debt securities similarly turns on the legal obligations created by an arrangement, including whether anyone has made an enforceable promise to repay. The organizations say the lending protocols they analyze do not necessarily create the debtor-creditor relationship associated with traditional lending.

For vaults, the paper focuses on who owns the underlying assets, whether users have independently exercisable redemption rights, and what authority a curator holds. It says a vault may deploy assets according to automated rules or strategies selected by a curator without creating a separate organization that owns those assets and issues securities representing interests in them. The authors also say a curator’s investment decisions, receipt tokens and shared smart contracts do not individually establish that an issuer exists for purposes of the Investment Company Act.

The paper distinguishes a curator’s investment discretion from custody. Smart contracts can constrain a curator through approved destinations, exposure limits, independent permissions and restrictions on withdrawals. Those controls can allow investment decisions to be implemented without giving the curator possession of client assets. The analysis, Veda says, depends on the actual authority available to each participant, including any indirect routes to control through upgrades or administrative permissions.

## The authors limit their conclusions to specific designs

The submission does not claim that every lending protocol or vault falls outside securities laws. Its conclusions depend on the architecture, contractual terms and allocation of rights and authority described in the paper. Different ownership arrangements, repayment promises, discretionary powers or withdrawal restrictions could change the analysis.

The distinction matters in the paper’s treatment of investment advice and custody. A curator paid to advise on securities may face investment-adviser requirements, the authors say, even if the curator cannot take possession of client assets. Their analysis turns on the curator’s actual powers and whether a contract or smart-contract design limits those powers. It also calls for examining whether administrative permissions or upgrade routes could provide indirect control.

## No SEC endorsement accompanies the submission

Veda’s blog post says the SEC has not endorsed the paper’s conclusions. The joint submission asks the Commission to recognize distinctions among issuance, investment management and custody under existing securities laws. The paper’s authors present their analysis as applying to the specific arrangements they describe, not as a request for a special regulatory pathway.

The framework’s broader argument is that familiar financial functions do not, by themselves, establish the legal relationships associated with traditional intermediaries. The authors say the relevant questions include who owns the assets, who assumes obligations and who exercises effective authority. They argue that the answers depend on the design and governing terms of each arrangement.

## Sources

1. Original source · Blog post [Veda](https://veda.tech/blog/why-veda-is-taking-the-future-of-onchain-finance-to-the-sec) veda.tech

## Related stories

- [Kamino Opens USDC Loans Against Four Tokenized Stocks](https://crypto.world/news/kamino-usdc-loans-tokenized-stocks-backpack-market)
- [SEC Makes Cboe EDGX Multi-Crypto Options Rules Operative](https://crypto.world/news/sec-cboe-edgx-multi-crypto-options-rules-operative)
- [Aave V4 Opens Three Sentora-Curated Lending Markets](https://crypto.world/news/aave-v4-sentora-curated-lending-markets)
- [SEC Staff Set Limits on When Crypto Governance Forms a Central Party](https://crypto.world/news/sec-crypto-governance-central-party-guidance)
- [SEC Refiles DEBT Box Case With $200M Fraud Allegations](https://crypto.world/news/sec-refiles-debt-box-case-200m-fraud-allegations)

## Explore

[More articles](https://crypto.world/news)

---

Canonical: https://crypto.world/news/aave-kamino-veda-sec-defi-lending-framework
