Skip to content
Crypto.world

The Ledger

Argentine Judge Dismisses $LIBRA Case Against Milei and 10 Others

Federal Judge Marcelo Martínez de Giorgi dismissed the criminal case over $LIBRA against Argentine President Javier Milei, his sister Karina and nine others on October 23. The ruling found prosecutors had not established the alleged crimes, while investors and an economic-crime watchdog criticized the case’s closure.

Argentine Judge Dismisses $LIBRA Case Against Milei and 10 Others

A dismissal opposed by investors

Federal Judge Marcelo Martínez de Giorgi dismissed the criminal case against Argentine President Javier Milei, his sister Karina and nine other people on Friday, October 23, ending the inquiry into their alleged roles in the launch of the $LIBRA token. The ruling followed a request by prosecutor Eduardo Taiano and came before Milei or the other defendants had been called to give formal testimony, according to LA NACION.

Source elpais.com

The decision drew immediate criticism from people who lost money in the token’s collapse, who have asked the Cassation Court to reinstate them in the case, and from the Center for the Investigation and Prevention of Economic Crime (CIPCE), which participated in the case as a friend of the court. “The dismissal in the $LIBRA case is a premature decision that does not take into account the relevance of the president’s role in promoting the crypto asset,” CIPCE executive director Pedro Biscay said (translated from Spanish).

The judge found no charge established

Martínez de Giorgi concluded that “the events reported do not fit a legal category,” rejecting allegations including fraud, influence peddling, abuse of authority and incompatible public-office dealings. He accepted that Milei’s office gave $LIBRA unusual visibility, but said that visibility alone did not establish a legally relevant deception or prove what falsehoods had induced buyers to trade.

The ruling also said investigators had not proved that Karina Milei requested or received money to arrange meetings between her brother and people behind the project. It found no demonstrated link between an alleged fraudulent scheme and investors’ losses, and said the distribution of gains and losses alone did not establish fraud.

More than 40,000 buyers lost money

The case began after Milei promoted $LIBRA on social media as a private project intended to fund small businesses and ventures in Argentina. The token’s price fell sharply hours after its launch. LA NACION, citing the resolution, reported that more than 40,000 buyers suffered losses while a small number of wallets withdrew about $100 million.

The judge’s ruling covered Milei and Karina Milei, as well as U.S. businessman Hayden Mark Davis, KIP Protocol’s Julian Peh, former securities regulator adviser Sergio Morales, Mauricio Novelli, and other people named in the investigation. The dismissal was not a finding that investors had avoided losses; it was a determination that the evidence in the criminal case did not establish the charged offenses.

Investigative gaps remain central to the dispute

The case file included digital evidence and records of crypto-asset movements, but the investigation did not resolve every question. Chequeado reported that forensic experts identified calls between Milei and Novelli on the day $LIBRA launched but could not determine what they discussed. Investigators also could not complete some tracing work because they lacked licensed technical tools, while responses from platforms were partial.

The ruling also addressed concerns about the handling of digital evidence. An administrative inquiry by the Attorney General’s office (PGN) found that an employee of DATIP, the prosecution service’s directorate for investigations and technological support, had accessed confidential case material, some of which later reached the press; Martínez de Giorgi said the incident weakened the chain of custody and the evidentiary value of related reports. He did not declare those reports null, but found that they did not establish the alleged criminal scheme when considered with the rest of the evidence.

Investors seek another review

Investors had already been removed as private complainants by a federal appeals court, a decision they are seeking to challenge before Argentina’s Federal Criminal Cassation Court. Their exclusion left the prosecutor’s request as the accusation before the judge, LA NACION reported.

That procedural dispute now sits alongside the divide over the ruling itself: Martínez de Giorgi found the evidence insufficient to continue, while CIPCE and affected investors say the case closed before the president’s promotion of the token was tested in a public trial. The judge’s October 23 decision dismissed the criminal case against all 11 people.

Sources

  1. Original source EL PAÍS elpais.com

Other pages read

  1. LA NACION lanacion.com.ar
  2. Chequeado chequeado.com
  3. Juzgado Nacional en lo Criminal y Correccional Federal N.º 8 (court ruling) drive.google.com

Related stories

Explore

More articles