Skip to content
Crypto.world

The Ledger

CFTC Chair Selig Puts Autonomous Trading on Regulatory Agenda

CFTC Chair Michael S. Selig raised questions about registration, liability and oversight as autonomous software begins handling financial transactions. His October 28 remarks set up a forum discussion on how the agency’s rules should apply when trading agents act for market participants.

CFTC Chair Selig Puts Autonomous Trading on Regulatory Agenda

CFTC Chair Michael S. Selig wants regulators to encourage autonomous financial software without leaving basic questions of responsibility unanswered. In remarks on October 28, he asked whether an agent’s developer might need registration, who would be liable if the software acted unexpectedly and whether regulators need a way to identify the agents trading for customers. He announced no new rule, but put those questions before a public forum on AI and agentic finance.

The CFTC’s rules were built around people and firms

“Who is liable if the agent goes rogue?” Selig asked in his opening remarks at the agency’s inaugural Frontier Forum. Michael S. Selig, CFTC chairman

The questions reflect a mismatch Selig sees between the agency’s existing framework and software that can act for a customer. “The CFTC’s regulatory framework was developed around identifiable market participants, intermediaries, and institutions performing specific financial functions,” he said. An agent that selects and executes trades on a user’s behalf complicates the task of deciding who is performing those functions—and who should answer for the results.

Selig raised the possibility of a new “know-your-agent” requirement, or KYA, alongside questions about registration and responsibility. He also said the agency’s approach should account for the functions performed, the control exercised and the economic realities of each transaction. Those remarks describe issues for regulators to consider, not a proposed registration regime or a settled legal test.

Crypto agents can bypass familiar intermediaries

Selig’s concern reaches beyond conventional brokerage tools. He said people are increasingly giving AI agents credentials for brokerage and bank accounts, while blockchains can let software hold and trade crypto assets without banks, brokerages or other traditional intermediaries. That combination could leave regulators with less clarity about who directs a transaction and on whose behalf it occurs.

The chair also identified risks that arise when autonomous systems respond to markets at speed. Agents may behave unexpectedly, he said, and systems based on similar models could trade in correlated ways. Faster transactions could also make market surveillance and risk management harder.

Selig balanced those warnings with potential uses for the technology. He said AI systems could help exchanges spot suspicious activity, assist clearinghouses in monitoring exposures and improve regulators’ ability to detect misconduct. The challenge he described is not simply whether to permit automated tools, but how to preserve oversight while software takes on more of the work.

Selig says the old algorithm proposal does not fit

The CFTC has addressed automated trading before. Selig pointed to the agency’s proposed Regulation Automated Trading, developed after the May 2010 Flash Crash, Knight Capital’s August 2012 algorithm failure and a disruption in Treasury futures in October 2014. The proposal sought special risk controls for algorithmic trading firms, but the commission never finalized it.

Selig said that proposal would be ill-suited to current conditions because AI tools have spread beyond sophisticated trading firms. Applications such as Claude, ChatGPT and Gemini can work with third-party tools to analyze market data, while brokerages are beginning to offer AI features to customers. His remarks suggest the agency is weighing a different problem from the one addressed by its earlier proposal: not only how firms control algorithms, but how to assign responsibility when a customer delegates financial activity to software.

The forum set questions, not a policy decision

The CFTC’s agenda scheduled a separate “Agentic Trading” session for 2:45 to 4 p.m. on October 28. It called for discussion of how autonomous systems interact with market infrastructure and whether, and how, the agency’s regulatory framework should apply when agents transact for market participants. The listed participants included Brett Harrison of Architect, Kush Bavaria of Ornn, Ronit Jain of Liquid Compute, and representatives of the Investment Company Institute and Hedera.

The event’s stated purpose was discussion of emerging technology and the CFTC’s role in supporting adoption while protecting market participants. Neither Selig’s remarks nor the published agenda announced a rulemaking or a timetable for new requirements. The concrete next step described by the agency was the forum itself: a scheduled examination of how its existing rules apply when software, rather than a person, carries out a financial transaction.

Sources

  1. Original source · Government or agency page CFTC · page 1 cftc.gov

Other pages read

  1. CFTC · page 2 cftc.gov

Related stories

Explore

More articles