# DeFi Education Fund urges FCA to tie rules to control

Published 2026-11-18 · Crypto.world Team · Crypto.world

> DeFi Education Fund has asked the UK regulator to assess DeFi participants by whether they can control user assets or transactions. Its responses address proposed guidance for regulated firms and the FCA’s draft cryptoasset regulatory perimeter.

## Control at the center

[DeFi Education Fund](https://www.defieducationfund.org/def-responds-to-the-fcas-defi-consultations/) has urged the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) to base DeFi-related regulatory obligations on whether a person can control users’ assets or transactions, rather than on a person’s role in developing or governing software. The fund set out that position in responses to two FCA consultations, published on November 18.

The consultations cover different parts of the proposed cryptoasset regime. GC26/7 sets out draft guidance for FCA-regulated firms that use or interact with DeFi; CP26/36 concerns draft guidance on the regulatory perimeter, including when cryptoasset activity may require authorization. Both consultations close on November 18, 2026.

## Proposed test for control

For its proposed control test, DEF said a person or group under common control would have control if it could unilaterally take custody of user assets or move them without consent; block, reorder or reverse a transaction; or change protocol code or parameters without approval from a dispersed, unaffiliated group of token holders or validators. The fund also proposed six indicators for assessing whether a protocol operates without a controlling person or entity: transparency, permissionless access, non-custodial design, no centralized network control, automated execution and no retained economic authority.

In its response to GC26/7, DEF asked the FCA to incorporate those control powers and indicators into firms’ assessments of DeFi protocols. It also asked the regulator to clarify that the guidance would not automatically impose obligations on developers, governance participants or infrastructure providers who lack unilateral control.

## Wallets and firm access

DEF challenged the draft’s treatment of non-custodial wallets as a possible financial-crime risk factor, arguing that self-custody should not itself trigger enhanced due diligence. It asked the FCA to have firms assess wallets by their on-chain exposure to illicit activity, using tools such as wallet screening and transaction monitoring.

On operational resilience, the fund asked the regulator to recognize audits, formal verification, bug bounties and public disclosure as evidence firms could consider. It also called for recognition that immutable code and timelocked upgrades can protect users from sudden changes. DEF further asked for guidance on how authorized firms can connect customers to DeFi using appropriate controls, given that they cannot use the technical services exclusion for providers that merely offer access.

## Perimeter questions

For CP26/36, DEF asked the FCA to clarify how its proposed perimeter applies to developers, governance participants, validators, node operators, liquidity providers and front-end providers. The fund said the key question should be whether a participant has continuing control over user assets or transactions, including when code is immutable or governed through decentralized processes.

DEF also asked the FCA to confirm that validating, ordering and recording transactions under rules that apply to all participants does not, by itself, amount to arranging or dealing. It sought clarification that a person supplying their own assets to a liquidity pool without presenting themselves as a liquidity service could rely on the proprietary trading exclusion. For front-ends, it asked the regulator to confirm that neutral protocol integration, screening and fixed, disclosed fees can be consistent with the technical services exclusion.

The FCA says it will consider consultation feedback and plans to publish final guidance in January 2027. DEF said its two responses follow an earlier submission on consultation paper CP25/40 in February 2026.

## Sources

1. Original source [DeFi Education Fund](https://www.defieducationfund.org/def-responds-to-the-fcas-defi-consultations/) defieducationfund.org

Other pages read

2. [Financial Conduct Authority · Gc26 decentralised finance guidance](https://www.fca.org.uk/publications/guidance-consultations/gc26-7-decentralised-finance-guidance) fca.org.uk
3. [Financial Conduct Authority · Cp26 cryptoasset perimeter guidance](https://www.fca.org.uk/publications/consultation-papers/cp26-36-cryptoasset-perimeter-guidance) fca.org.uk

## Related stories

- [FCA Proposes New Crypto Crime Guidance Ahead of 2027 Rules](https://crypto.world/news/fca-proposes-crypto-financial-crime-guidance)
- [Uniswap, a16z Ask Illinois to Rewrite DeFi Tax Rules](https://crypto.world/news/uniswap-a16z-illinois-defi-tax-rules)
- [Japan FSA minutes raise redemption and DeFi regulatory questions](https://crypto.world/news/japan-fsa-on-chain-finance-study-group-minutes)
- [UK FCA Says Crypto Apps That Pick Trade Routes May Need Authorisation](https://crypto.world/news/uk-fca-crypto-apps-trade-routes-authorisation)
- [Name.com Restores 15 Domains After Attack Hits DeFi Sites](https://crypto.world/news/name-com-restores-domains-defi-website-hijack)

## Explore

[More articles](https://crypto.world/news)

---

Canonical: https://crypto.world/news/defi-education-fund-fca-control-consultations
