Skip to content
Crypto.world

The Ledger

Elektron says Bitcoin mining concentration falls with operator-level counting

Elektron Energy says Bitcoin mining pool charts overstate concentration, reporting an HHI score of about 1,520. Its white paper says the estimate falls as low as 1,100 when large operators splitting hashrate among pools are counted independently.

Elektron says Bitcoin mining concentration falls with operator-level counting

Pool charts and operator counts

Elektron Energy, a bitcoin miner, said in a Nov. 18 release that the HHI concentration score of bitcoin mining is about 1,520 when measured by pool block finds over one year, and as low as 1,100 when large operators that divide computing power among several pools are counted separately. The company’s white paper, “Profit Maximization and Protocol Risk,” evaluates mining concentration through technical and economic measures and says neither points to high concentration.

Source prnewswire.com

The analysis uses public and proprietary operating data to examine mining strategies, pool centralization and control of block templates. Elektron argues that commonly cited charts of pool market share can give an incomplete picture because operators may spread their hashrate across several pools, even when blocks are credited to those pools individually.

How the concentration estimate changes

Using the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index, or HHI, the company puts pool block findings over a one-year period at about 1,520. The HHI is described in the release as the standard economic measure of market concentration. Elektron compares the result with the 1,800 level that the 2023 U.S. Merger Guidelines treat as highly concentrated.

When large operators that split their hashrate across several pools are counted independently, Elektron says, the estimate falls as low as 1,100. That calculation changes the counted entities from pools to operators that use multiple pools; the company presents it as a lower estimate of concentration.

The findings, according to Elektron, point to strategic use of multiple pools and control over block templates as relevant to decentralization. Pool block-share charts track which pool finds a block, while the company’s operator-level calculation accounts for large miners that distribute hashrate across pools.

Template choice and pool services

The release identifies DATUM and Stratum V2 as existing protocols that allow a miner’s own node to select the transactions included in a block, while a pool continues share accounting and pays contributors. Elektron says this arrangement separates transaction selection from the pool’s role in organizing contributed computing power and distributing payouts.

The company’s white paper also considers the economics of pool choice. It says that over time a unit of hashrate earns equivalently across any fair pool, while payment models, fees and operating risks vary. The release frames those differences as business considerations for miners rather than as differences in expected earnings across fair pools.

Payout comparison

For 2025, Elektron says two large full-pay-per-share pools paid within 0.2 sats per TH per day of each other in every month. The comparison is limited to those two pools and that period. Full-pay-per-share pools handle payout variance through their payment model, while the release says pools differ in how they handle variance, what they charge and their operating risks.

San Naidoo, Elektron Energy’s president, said granular data from miners is missing from widely used pool charts. The company said its paper aims to share insight into operator practices and risk controls, and argued that miners can use multi-pool strategies and template control to help keep mining decentralized.

Sources

  1. Original source · Press release PR Newswire prnewswire.com

Related stories

Explore

More articles