Skip to content
Crypto.world

The Ledger

Japan FSA minutes raise redemption and DeFi regulatory questions

A Japanese financial regulator’s study group discussed whether large redemption requests could trigger sales of government bonds backing electronic payment instruments. Minutes from its first meeting also record questions about DeFi oversight, tokenized deposits and securities transfers.

Japan FSA minutes raise redemption and DeFi regulatory questions

Large redemption requests at major electronic payment instrument issuers could lead to sales of the government bonds backing them, an opinion recorded by a Japanese financial regulator’s study group says. Japan’s Financial Services Agency published the group’s first meeting summary on November 11, setting out questions about whether existing rules are sufficient.

The group met on October 20. Its agenda included a secretariat briefing, hearings with Nomura Holdings and Securitize Japan, and a discussion. The opinions in the Japanese-language summary are presented as discussion points, not as adopted rules.

Deposits and redemption risks

The study group was convened to examine frameworks for asset tokenization, stablecoins, decentralized exchanges, decentralized finance and wallet providers. The opinions recorded at its first meeting ranged from how to support the use of tokenized assets to how to address risks associated with them.

One view recorded in the summary held that international interest in stablecoins was declining while interest in tokenized deposits was growing, citing price fluctuations and anti-money-laundering hurdles for international transfers. The same opinion said work had begun on interoperability between tokenized deposits and urged a balanced discussion that takes overseas developments into account.

A separate view questioned whether current rules sufficiently address lending of electronic payment instruments when it is offered alongside issuance, because the combination can look like investment solicitation. The potential sale of government bonds following large redemption requests was another reason raised for checking whether regulation is adequate.

DeFi and investor protection

On decentralized exchanges and DeFi, one opinion urged a fuller discussion of how to approach those services before considering the form of regulation. The minutes also record a call to discuss how Japan should respond to the Financial Action Task Force’s DeFi report from an anti-money-laundering perspective.

Other opinions called for identifying the appropriate subjects and methods of regulation, with timely action to prevent Japan from becoming a place for regulatory gaps or arbitrage. The discussion also raised investor protection and market integrity as priorities, along with the question of who would perform the gatekeeper role traditionally played by financial institutions.

Transfers and securities

A view on blockchain transfers described a fundamental change from managing customers and transactions by account to managing them by signing key. That opinion called for priority discussion of improving transfers and for clarifying responsibility when problems occur.

Another possible approach raised in the meeting was to build arrangements that supplement existing systems, based on the current framework, to support operation 24 hours a day, 365 days a year and links with other systems. Participants also raised the need to examine obstacles to pursuing developments in Japan similar to activity by overseas institutions.

For security tokens, one opinion proposed permitting securities to be issued without physical certificates where the law requires them. Another suggested examining tokenization of highly liquid assets such as listed shares.

On shorter securities settlement, one view called for a discussion separate from tokenization. Another called for attention to the risk of abrupt changes in securities markets and the channels through which effects could spread across the financial system, as well as possible measures to mitigate or stop that spread.

Testing and safeguards

The discussion included a view that experiments would help reveal benefits, disadvantages and risks that are otherwise difficult to establish. One opinion cautioned that connections with public blockchains could create uncertainty around anti-money-laundering measures and financial institutions’ safe custody of assets and their return to rightful holders.

The minutes also record a call for service providers to disclose the scope and standards of system audits and verification, and for incident arrangements to specify or communicate who can stop what and to what extent. Other issues raised for consideration included settlement finality and requirements for asserting rights against third parties.

Sources

  1. Original source · Government or agency page Japan Financial Services Agency · page 1 fsa.go.jp

Other pages read

  1. Japan Financial Services Agency · page 2 fsa.go.jp
  2. Japan Financial Services Agency · page 3 fsa.go.jp
  3. fsa.go.jp
  4. jp-reports.com

Related stories

Explore

More articles