# Preprint proposes fee-memory rule for Layer 2 posting costs

Published 2026-11-17 · Crypto.world Team · Crypto.world

> A Nov. 16 preprint models Layer 2 posting fees as a vault that collects user fees and pays Layer 1 data-posting costs. Its authors report that their proposed rule reduced benchmark tracking error by about one third at the fee movement implied by Arbitrum’s current parameters.

A Nov. 16 preprint proposes a feedback rule for Layer 2 fees that would use a rollup’s accumulated balance to adjust what users pay for Layer 1 data posting. Authors Ulysse Pavloff and Lin Oshitani model that accounting position as a “vault” and report that their rule reduced benchmark tracking error by about one third at the fee movement implied by Arbitrum’s current parameters.

Source [arxiv.org](https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.20838)

## A balance-based fee model

The paper treats user fees as deposits into the vault and Layer 1 posting costs as withdrawals. Because revenue-cost differences accumulate over time, the authors distinguish recovering each interval’s posting cost from keeping the vault near a target balance. A fee that merely passes through the current cost can leave an existing surplus or shortfall untouched.

The proposed rule keeps a fraction of the previous fee and adds a correction proportional to the current vault error. The retained fraction, which the paper calls the fee-memory coefficient, sets a trade-off between tracking the target balance and limiting fee changes. More fee memory makes fees smoother but, in the model, allows balance errors to persist longer.

The closed-form analysis assumes fixed, price-independent transaction volume, a correctly known and constant mean posting cost, unpredictable cost deviations and fees without a lower or upper bound. The historical replay instead applies a zero fee floor and no upper cap. The authors caution that clipping fees at zero removes the optimality guarantee derived for the unconstrained benchmark.

## Comparison with existing controllers

The paper compares its rule with proportional and proportional-integral controllers and an adaptation of Arbitrum Nitro’s pricing rule. In the idealized benchmark, the authors say their optimal rule achieves about one third less tracking error than the Arbitrum-style rule at the fee movement implied by Arbitrum’s current parameters.

The historical evaluation uses seven months of Ethereum fee data and a modeled workload. At the middle setting, the proposed LQR controller recorded a vault root-mean-square error of 0.0249 ETH and fee movement of 4.9%. The proportional-integral controller’s corresponding error was 0.41 ETH, with fee movement of 7.63%; the paper links much of its error to a surplus retained after Oct. 10 by the anti-windup rule used in the test.

Those results do not establish an empirical optimum: the authors describe the replay as a stress test, not a validation of the benchmark. Their evaluation covers one Layer 1 price trace and one blob-fee regime, with fixed posting cadence and payload. It also uses a full-window mean cost as a retrospective calibration, which the paper notes would not be available at deployment.

## Limits and open questions

The authors report that adjacent posting costs in the historical data had a correlation of 0.979, meaning the previous cost could help predict the next one.

Other limitations include fixed demand and the absence of a model for users changing activity in response to fees. The paper also says a fee cap can dominate the controller: in its capped test, the reserve size and cap determined downside outcomes during an October spike, rather than the choice of feedback rule.

## Sources

1. Original source · Preprint [Optimal Dynamic Fees for L2s: A Vault Approach](https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.20838) arXiv:2611.20838

## Related stories

- [Preprint proposes one-transaction proofs for Ethereum quantum migration](https://crypto.world/news/researchers-propose-one-transaction-proofs-ethereum-quantum-migration)
- [Lightning force-closes cost 2–6 times more in fees, preprint finds](https://crypto.world/news/study-lightning-force-close-fee-cost)
- [Researchers update Angelfish consensus preprint](https://crypto.world/news/researchers-update-angelfish-consensus-preprint)
- [Researchers map trade-offs across Tendermint consensus designs](https://crypto.world/news/researchers-map-tendermint-consensus-design-tradeoffs)
- [Ethereum IoT preprint finds batched ECDSA costs 8,963 gas per record](https://crypto.world/news/ethereum-iot-authentication-cost-study-pectra-fusaka)

## Explore

[More articles](https://crypto.world/news)

---

Canonical: https://crypto.world/news/preprint-layer-2-dynamic-fees-vault-approach
