The Ledger
Solana Policy Institute asks SEC to define a permissionless-ledger test
The Solana Policy Institute asked the SEC to judge permissionless ledgers by who controls transaction ordering, validation and network rules. Its October 22 comment proposes five factors and a narrow exception for temporary emergency responses.

“That description addresses access but leaves important questions about control unanswered.”
Miller Whitehouse-Levine, CEO, and Patrick Wilson, General Counsel, Solana Policy Institute
The SEC’s exemption makes ledger status a condition
The Solana Policy Institute asked the Securities and Exchange Commission on October 22 to define what qualifies as a “public, permissionless distributed ledger” under its tokenized-stock trading exemption. The group wants the SEC to assess control over transaction processing and network rules, not just whether people can access the ledger. Its comment letter was signed by CEO Miller Whitehouse-Levine and General Counsel Patrick Wilson.
The SEC’s September 17 order grants conditional, five-year relief from the Exchange Act’s “exchange” definition to certain venues trading tokenized National Market System stocks through permissioned automated market makers and liquidity pools. It also provides conditional “dealer” relief for certain liquidity providers. Among the conditions, venue smart contracts must be auditable and public, and deployed on a public, permissionless ledger.
The order says “permissionless” generally means anyone can read or write to the ledger without authorization, the institute writes. That addresses who can submit or view transactions, but not who decides whether a transaction is included, how it is ordered, who validates or finalizes blocks, or who can change the rules. The institute argues those control questions affect whether the ledger can deliver the transparency and resilience the SEC seeks.
Five factors turn on control, not a named chain
The institute recommends that the SEC issue guidance or FAQs on five considerations. They include whether the ledger’s protocol and code are open source; whether anyone can read it and submit valid transactions without individual authorization; and whether it executes transactions under pre-established, transparent rules.
The remaining factors examine whether a person or commonly controlled group has persistent or structurally exclusive power over transaction sequencing, validation, inclusion, finality or consensus rules. The SEC should also consider whether such a party can restrict or censor use, or receives preferential treatment through private permissions or hard-coded privileges. The letter does not ask the agency to prescribe a specific ledger architecture.
To frame its proposed control factors, the institute points to concepts in the Senate Banking Committee’s discussion draft of the Digital Asset Market Clarity Act, released September 14. The draft addresses control over ledger functionality and consensus, as well as unilateral power to restrict or censor system use. The institute recommends that the SEC draw from that approach when interpreting the exemption’s ledger condition.
Emergency pauses would not automatically disqualify a ledger
The letter proposes a limited carveout for incident response. A network should not fail the standard solely because it can pause operations or deploy an emergency patch to address a critical vulnerability, the institute says. It would condition that treatment on advance public disclosure, measures limited in duration and scope to what the incident requires, and post-incident reporting.
The group says those safeguards would allow operators to respond to threats without granting them ongoing centralized control. The distinction matters to its wider proposal: emergency authority alone would not settle whether a network qualifies, but its design and limits would factor into the control assessment.
Guidance could shape venues’ infrastructure choices
The institute says prospective tokenized-securities venues are already choosing which networks to build on, and that changing those choices later could be costly. It asks the SEC to clarify the standard promptly so venues can plan their systems and compliance around a clearer rule.
The filing is a request for guidance, not a change to the SEC’s order or a determination that any particular network qualifies. The exemption still requires public smart contracts on a public, permissionless ledger; the institute’s proposed test would make the decisive question more specific: who can order, include or validate transactions, and who can change the rules governing those powers.
Sources
- Original source · Government or agency page U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission · page 1 sec.gov
Other pages read
Related stories
- Three Firms Prepare Tokenized U.S. Stock Venues Under SEC Exemption
- 22 Companies Object to Tokenized Shares on OKX-ICE Venue
- OKX-ICE Stock-Token Objections Reach 26 After Four More Issuers Opt Out
- 16 Companies Object to OKX-ICE Tokenized Stock Venue
- Amazon, Tesla and SpaceX object to OKX-ICE stock-token plan