Skip to content
Crypto.world

The Ledger

Spiral Says Bitcoin Payments Have a Demand Problem

Spiral says Bitcoin payment infrastructure has improved, but everyday use remains limited as merchants and holders have little reason to choose it. Its report proposes experiments to test whether shared payment rails, incentives and new uses can encourage people to spend Bitcoin.

Spiral Says Bitcoin Payments Have a Demand Problem

More than 1 million merchants, few Bitcoin payments

More than 1 million U.S. merchants can accept Bitcoin through Square, yet few people use Bitcoin for everyday purchases, Spiral says. The figure measures merchant access, not how often customers pay in BTC. In a report published on GitHub on October 27, Block’s open-source Bitcoin group argues that payment infrastructure has advanced while routine use has not followed.

“The problem is demand, not technology.”

The report’s authors write.

The report says Lightning infrastructure now runs in production and self-custodial wallets have hidden much of the complexity that once made payment apps difficult to build. Custodial Bitcoin is now no harder to integrate than custodial stablecoins, Spiral says, though self-custodial systems remain harder to operate at scale.

Stablecoins are becoming the default rail

Spiral’s concern is that new payment systems are being built around stablecoins rather than Bitcoin. The report points to Stripe, Shopify and Coinbase as companies building stablecoin payments into their services, and says early protocols for AI-agent payments settle almost entirely in stablecoins. Those choices could shape which networks developers support and which options users see in their wallets.

AI services sharpen the contrast: agents need small, programmable payments, a use case Spiral says suits Lightning, but early agent-payment tools are being built around stablecoins and cards. The report does not claim those choices are irreversible. It warns that if the rails become entrenched, Bitcoin could find it harder to gain a place later; if payment systems remain easy to adapt, weak consumer demand may still be the central obstacle.

Holders save; merchants wait for customers

Spiral describes a two-sided demand problem. Holders often treat Bitcoin as savings and avoid spending an asset they expect to appreciate, while merchants prefer to receive dollars and see little reason to add a payment option customers rarely request. Consumers also commonly need to buy Bitcoin through an exchange or app before spending it, adding a step that card and dollar-payment users do not face.

Price volatility makes it difficult to set prices in Bitcoin and encourages merchants or payment apps to convert receipts into dollars. Stablecoins address that preference for a steady dollar value, while Bitcoin offers different properties, including payments that do not rely on an issuer who can freeze funds. Spiral also identifies U.S. tax treatment as friction: spending Bitcoin counts as disposing of property and can require reporting a gain or loss, even on a small purchase.

Spiral wants tests, not just better wallets

The report proposes four paths for experiments: shared Lightning rails for dollar and Bitcoin payments; self-custodial payments for people facing capital controls or unstable currencies; discounts or rewards to encourage Bitcoin spending; and new micropayment experiences, such as paying creators or AI services per use. Spiral says it does not know which, if any, will work and asks builders to propose and test ideas, payment providers to share data, and funders to support promising experiments.

It also draws a distinction between spending Bitcoin and using Bitcoin infrastructure to route a dollar payment. To judge whether an experiment changes Bitcoin use, Spiral wants teams to track how many customers spend BTC, whether they pay again, and the number, value and share of payments funded in Bitcoin. The report’s central test is whether people keep spending after incentives end—not simply whether a merchant or app can technically accept the payment.

Sources

  1. Original source Spiral on GitHub github.com

Other pages read

  1. Delving Bitcoin delvingbitcoin.org

Related stories

Explore

More articles