# UK FCA Says Crypto Apps That Pick Trade Routes May Need Authorisation

Published 2026-10-27 · Crypto.world Team · Crypto.world

> The UK Financial Conduct Authority says crypto apps that choose or rank trade routes may fall outside a proposed technical-services exclusion. The FCA consultation closes on 18 November 2026, ahead of a crypto authorisation regime scheduled to begin on 25 October 2027.

> The fact that software uses an algorithm does not necessarily make the service non-discretionary.
>
> The authors of “CP26/36: Cryptoasset Perimeter Guidance”

## Route selection can move an app inside the perimeter

The UK Financial Conduct Authority is proposing guidance that could put some crypto trading apps on the authorisation track if their software helps decide where or how a customer’s trade is executed. Published on 21 October, consultation paper CP26/36 says the proposed technical-services exclusion is for providers that merely give users access to a third-party service or decentralised protocol. An app that selects or adjusts a route based on price, liquidity, speed, transaction costs, counterparty risk or likely outcome may be doing more than providing access.

The question is not whether a firm calls its product a wallet, interface or software tool. The draft asks what the service does in practice and whether the provider participates in arranging a transaction. The FCA says an app that exercises a regulated activity by way of business in the UK will need authorisation unless an exclusion applies; the proposal does not make every crypto app or routing tool automatically subject to licensing.

## Objective rules may still qualify for the exclusion

The consultation gives firms factors pointing in both directions. A service is more likely to remain within the proposed exclusion when the user chooses the provider or protocol, the app transmits the user’s instruction without qualitative judgment, and routing follows predetermined objective rules. The FCA also says the same input ordinarily producing the same output without intervention or qualitative assessment can indicate a non-discretionary service.

By contrast, the draft flags choosing among liquidity sources or execution venues, ranking options on their merits, changing an instruction, deciding when it is sent, or promising best execution. No single factor settles the question, and the regulator says firms must assess the service and arrangements as a whole. Software does not erase provider involvement: an algorithm may carry out judgments made earlier by its operator or apply criteria that the operator sets or changes.

The proposed carve-out has limits beyond routing. It applies to arranging deals, not other regulated activities such as dealing, and only where the provider is neither an FCA-authorised person nor a payment service provider. The FCA says a technical component inside a wider transaction service does not by itself bring the whole service within the exclusion.

## Applications are open before the rules begin

The FCA’s new crypto regime is scheduled to take effect on 25 October 2027. The application period for firms with existing UK crypto businesses opened on 30 September 2026 and closes on 28 February 2027; firms seeking to benefit from the savings provision must apply within that window. Responses to CP26/36 are due by 18 November.

The regulator says it will allow extra time for parts of an application relating to arranging permission if a firm shows that uncertainty over the technical-services exclusion materially affected its ability to submit a complete application. The firm must still submit an otherwise complete application during the application period and should contact the FCA through its pre-application support service. The consultation paper says final guidance is due in spring 2027, while the FCA’s consultation webpage says it aims to publish it in January 2027.

## The dividing line is the provider’s role

For a DeFi aggregator, the practical distinction is whether its software simply passes on a user’s choice or makes meaningful choices among routes and venues itself. An automated swap feature may therefore require close review of who selects the destination, which routing criteria the provider controls, and whether the app makes judgments about competing transaction options. The FCA’s draft leaves that assessment to each service’s functions and operating arrangements, rather than treating automation or decentralisation as a blanket exemption.

## Sources

1. Original source · Government or agency page [Financial Conduct Authority · page 1](https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/consultation/cp26-36.pdf) fca.org.uk

Other pages read

2. [Financial Conduct Authority · Cp26 cryptoasset perimeter guidance](https://www.fca.org.uk/publications/consultation-papers/cp26-36-cryptoasset-perimeter-guidance) fca.org.uk

## Related stories

- [UK FCA Opens DeFi Consultation on Existing Compliance Duties](https://crypto.world/news/uk-fca-defi-guidance-consultation-compliance-duties)
- [France Seeks MiCA Accountability Rules for DeFi Gateways](https://crypto.world/news/france-mica-accountability-defi-gateways)
- [Bessent Ties Crypto Leadership to the Dollar at Ripple’s Swell](https://crypto.world/news/bessent-crypto-dollar-strategy-ripple-swell)
- [Japan’s LDP Blockchain Group Hears JBA Call for Crypto Property Rights](https://crypto.world/news/japan-ldp-jba-crypto-property-rights-proposal)
- [Itaú Notifies Brazil’s Central Bank of Crypto Brokerage](https://crypto.world/news/itau-notifies-brazil-central-bank-crypto-brokerage)

## Explore

[More articles](https://crypto.world/news)

---

Canonical: https://crypto.world/news/uk-fca-crypto-apps-trade-routes-authorisation
