# Uniswap, a16z Ask Illinois to Rewrite DeFi Tax Rules

Published 2026-10-31 · Crypto.world Team · Crypto.world

> Andreessen Horowitz, DeFi Education Fund and Uniswap Labs asked Illinois to revise draft rules for its Digital Asset Tax Act, arguing the proposal could impose tax-collection duties on decentralized exchanges and software interfaces. Their letter also challenges proposed recordkeeping and the treatment of transfers to users’ own wallets and across blockchains.

[Uniswap Labs](https://crypto.world/companies/uniswap-labs), a16z and the [DeFi Education Fund](https://www.defieducationfund.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/a16z-DEF-Uniswap-Labs-response-to-the-IL-Department-of-Revenue-10.30.2026.docx.pdf) filed a joint comment letter with the Illinois Department of Revenue on October 30, asking the state to revise draft rules for its Digital Asset Tax Act. The groups argue that parts of the proposal could impose tax-collection duties on decentralized exchanges and software interfaces that do not hold users’ assets or act as intermediaries.

The submission challenges proposed recordkeeping involving private keys and the treatment of transfers to users’ own wallets and across blockchains. Illinois’ comment period closed at 5 p.m. on October 30, the deadline set by the Department of Revenue.

## Why the groups dispute broker status

Illinois’ draft says a 0.2% tax applies to the value of a digital asset connected to covered business activity received by an Illinois customer from a digital asset broker. The rules assign brokers duties that include collecting the tax and keeping records. The draft also lists decentralized exchanges that collect protocol fees among potential brokers.

The commenters say that definition reaches beyond the statute’s incorporation of a federal broker definition. In their account, DEX users direct and authorize trades from self-custodied wallets, while smart contracts execute transactions; interface providers help users submit instructions but do not take control of their assets. The groups ask Illinois to confirm that neither a DEX nor its interface becomes a broker merely by providing software or collecting a protocol or interface fee.

The letter is signed on behalf of the organizations by Miles Jennings, a16z frontier’s head of policy and general counsel; Amanda Tuminelli, DeFi Education Fund’s CEO and chief legal officer; Robert Pratt, Uniswap Labs’ general counsel; Michele R. Korver, a16z frontier’s head of regulatory; Ayana Dow, DeFi Education Fund’s senior counsel; Brian Nistler, Uniswap Labs’ head of policy; Jai Ramaswamy, a16z’s chief legal officer; and Scott Walker, a16z’s chief compliance officer. The signatories write:

> “Requiring DEXs to conduct intermediary functions such as customer identification or information collection would act as a ‘re-intermediation’ of a disintermediated system and a de facto ban on the technology.”

Joint comment letter signed on behalf of Andreessen Horowitz, DeFi Education Fund and Uniswap Labs

## Fee rules and private-key records

The draft distinguishes among fees. It excludes network fees and swap fees directed solely to liquidity providers from “valuable consideration,” but treats protocol fees as consideration and identifies fee-collecting DEXs as possible brokers. The groups want the department to define protocol fees separately from interface fees and state that collecting either type alone does not establish broker status.

They also object to a draft recordkeeping provision that calls for records of digital-asset movements “including private keys.” A private key can authorize transactions involving the assets tied to a wallet, the letter says, so storing copies could expose customers’ funds to theft. The signatories ask the department to replace “private keys” with “public keys,” which, alongside transaction identifiers, can document asset movements without granting control over funds.

## Own-wallet transfers and bridges are also in dispute

The comments challenge draft examples that treat a paid withdrawal from a custodial exchange to a user’s own wallet as taxable, as well as a broker-assisted transfer between wallets owned by the same person. The groups argue that these movements change custody or location, not ownership. They make a similar case for bridging assets between blockchains, warning that recording the movement on two chains could count one transfer twice under the draft’s occurrence rules.

The requested changes would exclude those movements when the user retains ownership. The groups also ask Illinois to delay the rules until a state court has ruled on the tax’s legality and, in any event, not put them into effect before July 1, 2027. A court-approved stay had already delayed implementation of the tax until that date. The letter’s request about the rules’ effective date is separate from the stay delaying implementation of the tax.

## Illinois’ draft remains open to revision

The Department of Revenue released the draft rules for public review in September, describing the comment process as an opportunity to flag unanswered questions and suggest examples. The joint submission is a request for changes to those proposed rules; it does not itself amend the law or decide how the department will respond.

The dispute turns on who can practically meet the rules’ requirements. The signatories say a noncustodial protocol cannot identify customers, determine where they live or collect tax on their behalf, while the draft’s treatment of fees and transfers could affect activity carried out through DeFi software.

## Sources

1. Original source [DeFi Education Fund (joint comment letter by Andreessen Horowitz, DeFi Education Fund and Uniswap Labs)](https://www.defieducationfund.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/a16z-DEF-Uniswap-Labs-response-to-the-IL-Department-of-Revenue-10.30.2026.docx.pdf) defieducationfund.org

Other pages read

2. [Illinois Department of Revenue · Digital asset tax draft proposed rules](https://tax.illinois.gov/content/dam/soi/en/web/tax/research/taxinformation/other/documents/digital-asset-tax-draft-proposed-rules-092826.pdf) tax.illinois.gov
3. [Illinois Department of Revenue · page 2](https://content.govdelivery.com/accounts/ILDOR/bulletins/42cdf21) content.govdelivery.com
4. [DeFi Education Fund](https://www.defieducationfund.org/defi-debrief-week-of-october-5-2026/) defieducationfund.org

## Related stories

- [a16z Crypto Renames Investment Arm a16z Frontier, Broadens Fund’s Focus](https://crypto.world/news/a16z-plans-rename-crypto-fund-a16z-frontier)
- [Uniswap Opens TJAR Fee Conversion to Outside Apps](https://crypto.world/news/uniswap-opens-tjar-fee-conversion-to-apps)
- [Uniswap Routes External DEX Liquidity Through v4 Hooks](https://crypto.world/news/uniswap-external-dex-liquidity-v4-aggregator-hooks)
- [CME Lists Uniswap Futures in 10,000- and 1,000-UNI Contracts](https://crypto.world/news/cme-lists-uniswap-futures)
- [Uniswap vote proposes v4 fees on five more chains](https://crypto.world/news/uniswap-vote-v4-fees-five-more-chains)

## Explore

[More articles](https://crypto.world/news)

---

Canonical: https://crypto.world/news/uniswap-a16z-illinois-defi-tax-rules
