Policy & Regulation
Is Writing Mixer Code a Crime? What the Tornado Cash Cases Settled
No US court has held that publishing non-custodial code is a crime. Roman Storm's conviction and the Samourai pleas rest on knowledge of criminal funds; the control test developers want lives in…

Is Tornado Cash Illegal? What Section 1960 Actually Prohibits
No US court has held that publishing software which never touches anyone's money is, by itself, a crime. The record built between 2024 and 2026 answers the developer question more narrowly than either side of the debate claims. The two US convictions of developers behind non-custodial mixers, Roman Storm's and Samourai Wallet's founders', both rest on what the defendants knew about the money moving through their services.
The protection developers invoke, that they never controlled users' funds, is not part of the law as any court has read it. The one judge to rule on the point declined to read a control requirement into Section 1960. Control appears instead in Justice Department charging policy and in bill text Congress has not passed, so a non-custodial developer's position today rests on prosecutorial discretion.
In one minute
- 18 U.S.C. 1960 can be broken three ways: no state licence, no federal registration, or knowingly moving criminal proceeds. The maximum is five years.
- A jury convicted Roman Storm on 6 August 2025 of conspiring to violate it on the knowledge theory, after prosecutors dropped the registration theory. It hung on the laundering and sanctions counts.
- Samourai Wallet's founders pleaded guilty on the knowledge theory and received five and four years.
- Fifteen days after the Storm verdict, the Justice Department said it would not approve new knowledge-prong charges against "truly decentralized" software.
- The Fifth Circuit held that Tornado Cash's immutable smart contracts cannot be blocked under IEEPA, and OFAC delisted Tornado Cash on 21 March 2025; neither step decided criminal liability.
- The statutory control test in S. 3611 has not been enacted, and the last Senate text before the September 2026 vote no longer mentioned Section 1960.
Section 1960 punishes whoever "knowingly conducts, controls, manages, supervises, directs, or owns all or part of an unlicensed money transmitting business", with up to five years in prison. The statute defines an unlicensed business three ways. Under subsection (b)(1)(A), a business is unlicensed if it operates without a licence in a state that makes doing so a crime, "whether or not the defendant knew" a licence was required. Under (b)(1)(B), it fails to register with FinCEN under 31 U.S.C. 5330.
The third prong is different in kind. Under (b)(1)(C), a business also qualifies if it "otherwise involves the transportation or transmission of funds that are known to the defendant to have been derived from a criminal offense or are intended to be used to promote or support unlawful activity." Nothing turns on a licence; the offence is moving money the defendant knows to be criminal proceeds or meant to fund crime. Conspiring to commit any of the three, under 18 U.S.C. 371, also carries a five-year maximum.
United States v. Storm: The Registration Theory Dropped, the Knowledge Theory Kept
Roman Storm, a co-founder of Tornado Cash, was indicted in the Southern District of New York in August 2023 (United States v. Storm, 23 Cr. 430). Before trial he argued that the money transmitting count failed because neither he nor the protocol ever controlled users' funds. On 26 September 2024 Judge Katherine Polk Failla rejected the argument. Ruling on the pleadings, she accepted the indictment's allegation that the business included "Tornado Cash's founders and network of relayers, and not merely the pool."
But getting back to the issue of control, the control requirement is not in the statute, and this Court is not going to read it in. — Katherine Polk Failla, United States District Judge, Southern District of New York
The same ruling refused to treat the case as one about code alone. The judge said she could not "simply accept Mr. Storm's narrative that he is being prosecuted merely for writing code," calling it "an overstatement of what's actually charged in the indictment." Her decision denied a motion to dismiss; it did not hold that any software is money transmission.
On 15 May 2025, in a letter over the name of US Attorney Jay Clayton, the government told the court it "will not proceed to trial" on the Section 1960(b)(1)(B) registration object of Count Two. It kept the (b)(1)(C) knowledge object and the other two counts. The letter said the office and the Office of the Deputy Attorney General had found the prosecution "consistent with the letter and spirit of the April 7, 2025 Memorandum."
Trial began on 14 July 2025. On 6 August the jury convicted Storm on Count Two, conspiracy to operate an unlicensed money transmitting business, and failed to reach unanimity on Count One, money-laundering conspiracy, and Count Three, conspiracy to violate sanctions law. The court declared a mistrial on those two counts. Storm stands convicted of neither laundering nor sanctions violations, and he has not been sentenced.
Control did not drop out of the case. Opposing his acquittal motion, the government argued that Storm kept "centralized control over essentially every component of the Tornado Cash service other than the pools where Tornado Cash user deposits were stored", citing the website, the router contract and the relayer system. The defense answered that the only control that matters is control over users' assets, which the founders never had, and asked Judge Failla to revisit her 2024 ruling.
Storm filed that Rule 29 motion on 30 September 2025, and it was argued on 9 April 2026. On 25 August 2026, citing the pending motion, Judge Failla adjourned the retrial on Counts One and Three to 26 April 2027, with a final pretrial conference on 20 April 2027. On 10 September she denied his request to dismiss those counts under the Speedy Trial Act. As of 21 October 2026 the docket showed no ruling on the acquittal motion.
Samourai Wallet: Two Guilty Pleas on the Knowledge Theory
Keonne Rodriguez and William Lonergan Hill, Samourai Wallet's chief executive and chief technology officer, were charged with money-laundering conspiracy and with a Section 1960 conspiracy resting on both the registration and the knowledge prongs. On 30 July 2025, before Judge Denise L. Cote, each pleaded guilty to one count of "conspiracy to operate a money transmitting business knowing the business transmitted crime proceeds", which carries a five-year maximum.
Judge Cote sentenced Rodriguez to five years on 6 November 2025 and Hill to four years on 19 November 2025. Each received three years of supervised release and a $250,000 fine. The prosecutors' release of 19 November 2025 describes Whirlpool, which "coordinated batches of Bitcoin exchanges between groups of Samourai users", and Ricochet, which added intermediate "hops" between addresses. It says the founders paid $6,367,139.69 in forfeiture, the fees Samourai earned, in satisfaction of an order to forfeit $237,832,360.55.
Samourai had said it never took custody of users' coins, and a dispute over that point preceded the pleas. On 1 April 2025 prosecutors disclosed a call held on or about 23 August 2023 with two FinCEN employees. In the government's own summary, the two said FinCEN guidance "has generally focused on custody" and that, under it, a mixer that does not take custody "would strongly suggest that Samourai is not acting as an MSB". The same summary says they could not predict what FinCEN's policy committee would decide.
The defense, in a letter filed on 6 May 2025, called the disclosure late Brady material and asked for a hearing. The government replied on 9 May that the call conveyed the "informal, individual" opinion of two employees not speaking for FinCEN, and that it touched at most the registration object of one count. Neither the laundering charge nor the knowledge object depended on FinCEN's view, the government argued, and the knowledge object was the one the founders later admitted.
On 15 December 2025 President Trump, asked in the Oval Office about a pardon for Rodriguez, said he would look at the case and turned to Attorney General Pam Bondi, who was present. The Justice Department's list of clemency grants by President Trump, updated on 20 October 2026, includes neither founder.
The Justice Department's Charging Policy
Developers cite two texts. Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche's memo of 7 April 2025, "Ending Regulation By Prosecution", said the department would no longer target "virtual currency exchanges, mixing and tumbling services, and offline wallets for the acts of their end users or unwitting violations of regulations", outside its stated enforcement priorities. It told prosecutors not to charge licensing and registration violations under Section 1960(b)(1)(A) and (B) without evidence the defendant knew of the requirement and broke it willfully. A footnote put (b)(1)(C) "outside the scope of this policy."
On 21 August 2025, in Jackson, Wyoming, Acting Assistant Attorney General Matthew R. Galeotti of the Criminal Division addressed that prong directly. Where "software is truly decentralized and solely automates peer-to-peer transactions, and where a third party does not have custody and control over user assets," he said, "new 1960(b)(1)(C) charges against the third-party will not be approved." He added that "if criminal intent is present, other charges may be appropriate."
Our view is that merely writing code, without ill-intent, is not a crime. — Matthew R. Galeotti, Acting Assistant Attorney General, Criminal Division, U.S. Department of Justice
The control test missing from the courtroom record appears here, in a prosecutor's speech. These texts bind only charging decisions inside the department. The memo states that it "does not, and may not be relied upon to create any right or benefit" enforceable at law, and in May 2025 Samourai's prosecutors quoted that disclaimer to ask the court not to consider the memo. Galeotti spoke of "new" charges "going forward". A later Attorney General can withdraw either text without a vote in Congress.
Neither text ended the pending Storm case. In October 2026 the office, now led by US Attorney James M. McDonald, was still briefing venue on Counts One and Two. Treasury's own mixer rulemaking runs on a separate track: on 6 October 2026 FinCEN withdrew its 2023 proposal to treat mixing as a class of transactions of primary money laundering concern.
Two Appeals Courts, Two Narrow Holdings
The sanctions question turned on a Fifth Circuit ruling. In Van Loon v. Department of the Treasury, decided on 26 November 2024 in an opinion by Judge Don R. Willett, six users challenged OFAC's 2022 designation. The pool contracts had been made unchangeable in a 2020 "trusted setup ceremony". The court held that the "immutable smart contracts at issue in this appeal are not property because they are not capable of being owned," so OFAC could not block them under IEEPA.
OFAC removed Tornado Cash and its listed Ethereum addresses from the sanctions list on 21 March 2025, lifting the ban on dealings with them that the designation had imposed; co-founder Roman Semenov stayed on the list under the North Korea programme. Van Loon was a civil case under the Administrative Procedure Act about what Treasury may block. It did not address whether writing, running or profiting from the software can be a crime, and Storm's criminal trial went ahead after it.
The second appellate ruling concerns a different design. On 25 September 2026 the D.C. Circuit affirmed the convictions and 150-month sentence of Roman Sterlingov, convicted by a jury of running Bitcoin Fog, including a Section 1960 count on the state-licensing prong. Bitcoin Fog users held accounts with the service. For venue on the conspiracy count, the court relied on the government's theory that Sterlingov or a co-conspirator mixed an undercover agent's bitcoin and transferred it on after being told it came from ecstasy sales; on the licensing counts, it relied on evidence that Bitcoin Fog served customers in the District.
Prosecutors cited the decision in Storm's case on 5 October 2026 to support venue. Storm's lawyers replied four days later that Bitcoin Fog "was a centralized, custodial mixer, unlike Tornado Cash, which was a noncustodial and permissionless protocol." Neither appellate court has decided whether a developer who never holds users' funds can be a money transmitter.
The Control Test Congress Drafted, Then Narrowed
S. 3611, the Blockchain Regulatory Certainty Act of 2026, introduced by Senator Cynthia Lummis with Senator Ron Wyden on 12 January 2026, defines a "non-controlling developer or provider" as one without "the legal right or the unilateral and independent ability to control, initiate upon demand, or effectuate transactions involving digital assets to which users are entitled." Such a person "shall not be treated as" a money transmitting business under 31 U.S.C. 5330, or as engaged in money transmitting as defined in Section 1960.
The House version of the market structure bill, H.R. 3633, passed on 17 July 2025 with a similar test in its Section 109. The substitute text Senator Lummis released on 10 September 2026 carried the Lummis-Wyden language as Section 10604, adding that it "shall not modify the application of section 1960(b)(1)(C)" to anyone who acts with specific intent to transfer funds known to be criminal proceeds.
The text released on 13 September, two days before the vote, went further. Its Section 10604 no longer mentions Section 1960, and the safe harbour became purely regulatory: a non-controlling developer would not be treated as a money transmitting business under 31 U.S.C. 5330, a money transmitter under FinCEN's rule, or one of two Bank Secrecy Act financial-institution categories. On 15 September 2026 the Senate rejected cloture on the motion to proceed to H.R. 3633 by 49 votes to 50.
What the Record Settles, and the Next Dates
Writing code alone has not been held a crime, and the one judge who addressed the claim said the indictment charged more than that. Every American conviction in this record rested on knowledge of the money or on handling it: Storm on the (b)(1)(C) theory, Samourai's founders by admission, Sterlingov for running a service that took in customers' bitcoin and paid it out again. Control is the line drawn by Justice Department policy and by draft legislation, not yet by the statute as read in court.
Abroad, the Rechtbank Oost-Brabant sentenced Alexey Pertsev, another Tornado Cash co-founder, to 64 months on 14 May 2024 for money laundering. Its summary says the service was built to perform automatically the acts essential to laundering, combining maximum anonymity with a serious lack of features enabling identification, control or detection. He appealed to the Gerechtshof 's-Hertogenbosch, which had not published a judgment by October 2026.
Judge Failla's ruling on the Rule 29 motion, including the request to revisit control, can come at any time. Unless that ruling changes it, the schedule runs to the government's expert disclosures on 5 February 2027, motions in limine on 30 March 2027, the final pretrial conference on 20 April 2027 and the retrial of Counts One and Three on 26 April 2027.
Sources
- United States v. Storm, No. 1:23-cr-00430 (S.D.N.Y.), docket (CourtListener) courtlistener.com
- United States v. Storm, Dkt. 97: transcript of decision on motions to dismiss (26 September 2024) storage.courtlistener.com
- United States v. Storm, Dkt. 144: government letter dropping the 1960(b)(1)(B) object (15 May 2025) storage.courtlistener.com
- United States v. Storm, Dkt. 224: jury verdict form (filed 7 August 2025) storage.courtlistener.com
- United States v. Storm, Dkt. 241: government opposition to Rule 29 motion (12 November 2025) storage.courtlistener.com
- United States v. Storm, Dkt. 242: defense reply in support of Rule 29 motion (12 December 2025) storage.courtlistener.com
- United States v. Storm, Dkt. 300: order adjourning retrial to 26 April 2027 (25 August 2026) storage.courtlistener.com
- United States v. Storm, Dkt. 303: order denying Speedy Trial Act dismissal (10 September 2026) storage.courtlistener.com
- United States v. Storm, Dkt. 305: government letter citing Sterlingov (5 October 2026) storage.courtlistener.com
- United States v. Storm, Dkt. 306: defense response on Sterlingov (9 October 2026) storage.courtlistener.com
- 18 U.S.C. 1960, Prohibition of unlicensed money transmitting businesses (LII) law.cornell.edu
- 18 U.S.C. 371, Conspiracy to commit offense or to defraud United States (LII) law.cornell.edu
- IRS-CI / SDNY, Founders of Samourai Wallet sentenced to five and four years in prison (19 November 2025) irs.gov
- IRS-CI / SDNY, Founders of Samourai Wallet plead guilty (6 August 2025) irs.gov
- United States v. Rodriguez and Hill, No. 24 Cr. 82, Dkt. 88: government response on FinCEN disclosure (9 May 2025) storage.courtlistener.com
- United States v. Rodriguez and Hill, No. 24 Cr. 82, Dkt. 87: defense letter on Brady disclosure (filed 6 May 2025) storage.courtlistener.com
- Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche, Ending Regulation By Prosecution (memorandum, 7 April 2025) justice.gov
- Acting Assistant Attorney General Matthew R. Galeotti, remarks at the American Innovation Project Summit, Jackson, WY (21 August 2025) justice.gov
- Van Loon v. Department of the Treasury, No. 23-50669 (5th Cir. 26 November 2024) ca5.uscourts.gov
- OFAC Recent Actions: Cyber-related Designation Removal; North Korea Designation Update and Removal (21 March 2025) ofac.treasury.gov
- United States v. Sterlingov, No. 24-3161 (D.C. Cir. 25 September 2026) media.cadc.uscourts.gov
- S. 3611, Blockchain Regulatory Certainty Act of 2026, as introduced (Congress.gov) congress.gov
- H.R. 3633, Digital Asset Market Clarity Act, engrossed in House (Congress.gov) congress.gov
- Senate amendment in the nature of a substitute to H.R. 3633, text of 10 September 2026 (EHF26718) lummis.senate.gov
- Senate amendment in the nature of a substitute to H.R. 3633, text of 13 September 2026 (EHF26724) lummis.senate.gov
- Senator Lummis, Lummis Releases Updated Clarity Act Text Ahead of Historic Tuesday Vote (10 September 2026) lummis.senate.gov
- U.S. Senate, Roll Call Vote 234, 119th Congress, 2nd Session (15 September 2026) senate.gov
- FinCEN, withdrawal of proposed special measure on CVC mixing (91 FR 63513, 6 October 2026) federalregister.gov
- Office of the Pardon Attorney, Clemency Grants by President Donald J. Trump (2025-Present), updated 20 October 2026 justice.gov
- Rechtbank Oost-Brabant, ECLI:NL:RBOBR:2024:2069 (14 May 2024) uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl
- Decrypt, Trump Says He Will 'Look At' Pardon for Samourai Bitcoin App Dev (15 December 2025) decrypt.co
- The Block, Trump to review pardon for Samourai Wallet co-founder Keonne Rodriguez (15 December 2025) theblock.co
- The Block, Tornado Cash developer Alexey Pertsev appeals conviction (16 May 2024) theblock.co
- Paul Hastings, Crypto Policy Tracker: Senate Republicans release updated Clarity Act text ahead of Sept. 15 cloture vote paulhastings.com