Skip to content
Crypto.world

The Crypto Industry

Reading a Stablecoin Attestation: What It Proves, What It Leaves Out

A reserve attestation proves one thing: at a stated minute, under criteria the issuer wrote, reserves covered the tokens it counted. Circle's and Tether's own reports show what sits outside that…

Reading a Stablecoin Attestation: What It Proves, What It Leaves Out

What a Reserve Attestation Is, and the One Question It Answers

A stablecoin reserve attestation answers one narrow question. At a stated minute, measured by criteria the issuer wrote itself, did the reserve assets equal or exceed the tokens the issuer counted as outstanding? An accountant's opinion that the answer is yes has value, but it is much less than most readers take from the word "attested".

The decisions that matter most lie outside that answer: in the criteria (which tokens count, and whether frozen coins and redemption fees are netted out), in what the engagement excludes (the days between snapshots, the notes, liquidity if a custodian fails, the holder's legal claim), and in the choice of standard. Read side by side, Circle's report for August 2026 and Tether's for 30 June 2026 show how differently two issuers can satisfy the same word.

An attestation has two authors. Management makes an assertion, here that reserves were at least equal to the tokens outstanding, and an independent practitioner gives an opinion on it. It is not an audit of financial statements: nobody opines on income, cash flows or the accounts as a whole. Exchange proof-of-reserves reports, which test customer balances with Merkle trees, are another instrument again, covered in our essay on exchange custody.

Circle's report is an examination under the attestation standards of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA), which require the accountant "to obtain reasonable assurance about whether management’s assertion is fairly stated, in all material respects". The letterhead and signature are those of Deloitte & Touche LLP in New York, and the opinion is dated 29 September 2026. Circle's transparency page describes the arrangement as monthly third-party assurance from "a Big Four accounting firm".

Tether's report is a reasonable-assurance engagement under a different standard, ISAE 3000 (Revised), the international standard for "Assurance Engagements Other than Audits or Reviews of Historical Financial Information". It is signed in Milan on 31 July 2026 by BDO Advisory Services S.r.l., partner Lelio Bigogno. The firm states that it was "engaged by Tether Global Investments Fund SICAF SA", which is not the issuer.

The cover has changed too. The report for 30 September 2025, signed by BDO Italia S.p.A., was titled "Independent Auditors' Report" and named no engaging party. Since the report for 31 December 2025 the title has read "Assurance Report According to ISAE 3000R", over the signer and engaging fund named above.

Circle's August 2026 Report: A Token Count Against a Ring-Fenced Pool

Circle's report carries two report dates, 11 August and 31 August 2026, each at 11:59pm Coordinated Universal Time. On 31 August it counts 73,320,757,305 USDC in circulation against a reserve with a fair value of $73,398,532,613. The margin between the two is $77,775,308.

The count is where the criteria do their work. "USDC in Circulation" is the total supply on Circle's approved blockchains, 75,065,131,879 on 31 August, minus three items. The first is 1,614,400,102 "Tokens Allowed But Not Issued", which exist on four chains for technical reasons. The second is 129,900,512 "Access Denied Tokens", restricted to comply with a law, regulation or legal order. The third is 73,960 tokens pending burn in Circle's Gateway contract.

Two smaller choices sit in the fine print. TRON is on the approved list, but only for redemptions, and 993,225 USDC permanently frozen on the deprecated FLOW blockchain fall outside the count altogether.

On 31 August the 129,900,512 Access Denied Tokens netted out of the count exceeded the $77,775,308 margin between reserve and circulation. That is not evidence of a shortfall, because the report is silent on whether assets are held against those coins; it leaves the question open. The OCC's final rule under the GENIUS Act, published in the Federal Register on 23 October 2026, reads restricted coins the other way: they "would remain payment stablecoins", with their reserves kept in segregated accounts until the restriction is resolved.

The reserve side is a ring-fenced pool. It consists of the Circle Reserve Fund, a government money market fund under Rule 2a-7 whose equity Circle Internet Financial, LLC holds "on behalf of USDC holders", plus segregated bank accounts kept apart from Circle's corporate funds. On 31 August the fund held $49,584,000,000 of Treasury repurchase agreements, $11,918,146,195 of Treasury bills and $1,003,409,582 of cash.

Outside the fund sat $9,591,096,978 of cash at regulated financial institutions and $1,301,292,779 of Treasury bills. Footnote 3 describes the repo as "the overnight lending of cash to global financial institutions which is overcollateralized by U.S. Treasury securities". The assertion is signed by Tamara Schulz, Chief Accounting Officer of Circle Internet Group, on 29 September 2026, four weeks after the last report date. Who keeps the income those assets earn is a separate question, taken up in our essay on the stablecoin yield ban.

Tether's 30 June 2026 Report: The Whole Company as Reserve

Tether's report measures something else. Its point in time is 30 June 2026 at 11:59pm UTC, and its "Reserves" include, in the report's words, "all assets owned by the Company". The comparison is therefore total assets against total liabilities: reserves of $187,751,426,411 against liabilities of $183,641,897,215, of which $183,622,105,630 relates to tokens issued. The excess of $4,109,529,196 is the company's equity, shown beside a comparative of $6,338 million at 31 December 2025.

Treasury bills are the largest item, at $114,960,963,604, followed by $18,625,552,412 of overnight reverse repurchase agreements and $6,993,428,950 of term reverse repo. With small amounts of non-US Treasury bills and bank deposits, cash equivalents total $140,642,627,095. The rest is $18,838,357,171 of precious metals, $13,453,749,726 of secured loans, $5,801,630,681 of bitcoin, $5,244,911,675 of "other investments", $3,761,438,892 of public equities and $8,711,171 of corporate bonds. Gold and bitcoin are valued at Bloomberg closing prices on the report date.

The accounting choices sit in the policies. Tokens are booked as refund liabilities "at the contractual redemption value of the tokens", a value that, by the report's definition, "takes into consideration the redemption fee of 10 basis points". Tokens in the treasury wallet are "authorized but not yet issued" and are not liabilities. Tokens the company holds outside that wallet, $808,077,231 on 30 June, "do not form any part of the assets or liabilities of the Company".

A reader cannot rebuild every step of that count. The footnote gives a gross redemption value of $184,588,527,295 for all tokens issued; subtracting the company-held tokens leaves $158,344,434 more than the token liability shown, a difference the report does not itemise. In the report for 31 December 2025 the same subtraction matched the liability to the dollar.

BDO's procedures included confirmations from banks and depositaries, a specialist's sample inventory of the gold, reconciliation of the ledgers to the blockchains and checks of collateral on a sample of secured loans. The Notes are outside the engagement: BDO does not "express an opinion or provide any assurance" on them. One of those unassured Notes carries the plainest claim in the document: "All Tether tokens are backed by an equivalent amount of assets held in Reserves."

The Emphasis of Matter sets four further limits. The engagement covers one point in time only. The going-concern assessment "requires significant judgment" and is not assured. Valuation "is based on normal trading conditions and does not reflect unexpected and extraordinary market conditions, or the case of key custodians or counterparties experiencing substantial illiquidity". And the company is a defendant in a New York class action, with no provision recognised. BDO's opinion "is not modified in respect of these matters".

Audit Versus Attestation: Two Figures for 31 December 2025

On 13 August 2026 Tether announced that KPMG U.S. had issued an unqualified opinion on the financial statements of Tether International, S.A. de C.V. for the year ended 31 December 2025, prepared under US generally accepted accounting principles. A KPMG U.S. spokesperson confirmed the opinion to The Block and said the work followed AICPA standards. An audit covers the whole set of statements, not one assertion.

Tether’s audited financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2025 report reserves exceeding the liabilities by $6.814 billion, confirming the quality of the public attestation reports. — Simon McWilliams, Chief Financial Officer, Tether

BDO's report for the same date gives a different number. It is prepared "using the recognition and measurement principles of IFRS", and on 31 December 2025 it shows assets exceeding liabilities by $6,337,833,551, the $6,338 million carried as the comparative in June. The gap to the audited figure is about $476 million. Neither document reconciles the two. They use different frameworks: US GAAP in the audit, and IFRS principles in a report that "does not represent the financial statements of the Company".

The audited statements themselves were not released with the announcement. As of 20 October 2026, the reports listed on Tether's transparency page were still the quarterly assurance reports, the latest for 30 June 2026.

What No Snapshot Shows

The days between. Deloitte's opinion covers two minutes in August. Circle also discloses reserve holdings weekly, and BlackRock publishes daily reporting on the fund's portfolio, but those disclosures sit outside the opinion. Tether says circulation figures are "typically published daily", while its assured figures come once a quarter; BDO writes that activity before and after 30 June "was not considered".

Counterparties and custodians. Neither report names the banks holding cash, the repo counterparties or the custodians of bills, gold and bitcoin, so concentration cannot be read from them. Circle's footnote says "global financial institutions". Tether's footnotes give maturities and a minimum A-3 rating for the "ultimate issuer or guarantor".

Liquidity under stress. Fair value at a quiet minute says nothing about what the assets would fetch on a day of mass redemptions. Tether's report states that limit in its emphasis paragraph. Circle's transparency page says the reserve "is designed to provide holders with ready liquidity, even under extremely stressed conditions", a design claim the examination does not test.

The holder's claim. An attestation tests existence and value, not who receives the assets if the issuer fails. Circle's criteria say the fund equity and segregated accounts are held on behalf of holders; Tether's report treats tokens as refund liabilities repayable on demand, listed with the company's other liabilities. For US permitted issuers, Section 11 of the GENIUS Act will give holders priority on required reserves in insolvency once the Act takes effect on 18 January 2027, as our GENIUS Act essay explains.

Comparability. Each issuer writes its own criteria. Circle compares a token count, with frozen coins netted out, against a segregated pool. Tether compares a whole company's assets against all its liabilities, with tokens booked at a fee-adjusted redemption value. Both reports end in the same "yes".

Five questions to ask of any attestation

  1. Who makes the assertion, who signs the opinion, and under which standard?
  2. What minute is measured, and how long after it was the report signed?
  3. Which tokens are counted, and which are netted out: unissued, frozen, company-held, on retired chains?
  4. Is the test a ring-fenced reserve against tokens, or a company's assets against all its liabilities?
  5. What is outside scope: the notes, liquidity, going concern, legal claims, the days between?

What the GENIUS Act Changes, and What It Leaves Open

Section 4(a)(1)(C) of the GENIUS Act requires each permitted issuer to publish monthly the number of its outstanding coins and the amount and composition of its reserves, "including the average tenor and geographic location of custody of each category of reserve instruments". Neither report above gives custody locations. Section 4(a)(3) requires the report to be examined each month by a "registered public accounting firm", a term section 2(26) takes from the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, where it means a firm registered with the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB).

The chief executive and chief financial officer must certify the monthly report's accuracy to the regulator. A knowingly false certification carries the criminal penalties of 18 U.S.C. 1350(c). Section 4(a)(10) adds a yearly audit for issuers with more than $50 billion outstanding that do not already report to the SEC: GAAP statements, audited under PCAOB standards and published on the issuer's website.

The OCC's final rule of 23 October 2026 sets the clock. Under its §15.11(e) and (f), an issuer must publish by noon on the last day of each month its reserve composition as of noon on the last day of the prior month, in a template that splits insured from uninsured deposits. The examination report must go up at the same time. Excess reserves may be withdrawn at any time, but only after "appropriate due diligence and confirmation that the withdrawal would not cause the reserve asset value to fall below outstanding issuance value"; the proposal would have allowed withdrawal only once a month, after the examination and certification.

The OCC had also asked whether to require an extra report as of a day "randomly selected each month" by the accountant; the final rule does not: the OCC is "not requiring an additional random floating day attestation at this time". In May 2026 the AICPA asked the OCC to build on its 2025 Criteria for Stablecoin Reporting: Part I for presentation and disclosure, covering token population, reserve composition, redemption terms, custody and risks to redeemability, and Part II for controls, added in January 2026. The August USDC report does not use them; its criteria are those "defined in the accompanying USDC Reserve Report".

The AICPA’s stablecoin criteria were developed through a rigorous, public process led by the accounting profession, and are already being used. — Sue Coffey, CEO of Public Accounting, American Institute of CPAs (AICPA)

The AICPA also cautioned against limiting these engagements "exclusively" to PCAOB-registered firms. Where the statute speaks, that request has little room: for the monthly examination and the large-issuer audit it names a registered firm, and the OCC's final rule defines the term exactly as section 2(26) does. The text leaves open the standard for the monthly examination, which section 4(a)(3) does not name. And for the large-issuer audit, section 4(a)(10)(A)(iv) says nothing in that subparagraph may "limit, alter, or expand the jurisdiction" of the PCAOB, so registration does not by itself bring inspection.

The First Examined Months Under the Act

The Act will make reports regular, but not comparable unless the criteria converge, and the OCC's final rule of 23 October 2026 points one way: it defines outstanding issuance value as "the total par value" of an issuer's coins, and its explanation keeps frozen coins in. Both choices described above, netting frozen coins out of the count and booking tokens at a fee-adjusted value, differ from that definition.

Section 20 sets the effective date at the earlier of 18 months after enactment, which falls on 18 January 2027, or 120 days after the primary federal regulators issue final rules. None had published one by 20 October 2026, and any rule issued from that day starts a clock that runs past 18 January, so the date holds. For an OCC-supervised permitted issuer, the timetable in the OCC's final rule of 23 October 2026 puts the first month-end after it, 31 January 2027, on the issuer's website with its examination report by noon on 28 February 2027.

Sources

  1. Circle, USDC Reserve Report and Independent Accountants' Report (Deloitte & Touche LLP), report dates 11 and 31 August 2026 6778953.fs1.hubspotusercontent-na1.net
  2. Tether International, Financial Figures and Reserves Report and BDO assurance report (ISAE 3000R), as of 30 June 2026 assets.ctfassets.net
  3. Tether International, Financial Figures and Reserves Report and BDO assurance report (ISAE 3000R), as of 31 December 2025 assets.ctfassets.net
  4. Tether International, Independent Auditors' Report on the Financials Figures and Reserves Report (BDO Italia S.p.A.), as of 30 September 2025 assets.ctfassets.net
  5. Tether, Transparency page and reports list (read 20 October 2026) tether.to
  6. Circle, Transparency and stability page (read 20 October 2026) circle.com
  7. Tether, Tether Completes the Largest Inaugural Financial Audit in History (13 August 2026) tether.io
  8. The Block, Tether says KPMG issued 'clean' opinion in first full audit of USDT issuer's financials (13 August 2026, KPMG U.S. confirmation) theblock.co
  9. GENIUS Act, Public Law 119-27 (GovInfo) govinfo.gov
  10. OCC, Implementing the GENIUS Act for the Issuance of Stablecoins (NPRM, 91 FR 10202, 2 March 2026) govinfo.gov
  11. 15 U.S.C. 7201 (Sarbanes-Oxley Act, section 2), definitions law.cornell.edu
  12. AICPA, AICPA Urges OCC to Leverage Established Stablecoin Reporting and Controls Criteria in GENIUS Act Rulemaking (May 2026) aicpa-cima.com
  13. AICPA, AICPA Updates Criteria for Stablecoin Reporting to Address Controls Over Stablecoin Operations (12 January 2026) aicpa-cima.com
  14. Federal Register, final rules mentioning 'payment stablecoin' (search, read 20 October 2026) federalregister.gov
  15. The Defiant, Tether clears first full audit from KPMG without publishing the statements (cross-check) thedefiant.io
  16. OCC, Implementing the GENIUS Act for the Issuance of Stablecoins (final rule, 91 FR 67000, 23 October 2026) federalregister.gov

Companies in this story

Related stories

Explore

More articles