The Crypto Industry
Are Tokenized Stocks Real Shares? Where US Rules Draw the Line
Some tokenized stocks are shares, some are entitlements held through DTC, and some are derivatives that only track a price. How the SEC, DTC and Nasdaq documents sort them, what each kind gives the…

Three Products Sold Under One Name
Some tokenized stocks are real shares, some are entitlements to shares that someone else holds, and some are contracts that only track a share's price. The US route to tokenized equities, set out in SEC and DTCC documents between December 2025 and September 2026, sorts them along that line. Under Nasdaq's approved rule, a tokenized share can trade only if it is fungible with its traditional class and stays inside the existing DTC holding chain. The blockchain changes the plumbing (collateral, settlement hours, margin), not who owns the share.
In one minute
- Issuer-sponsored token: the issuer or its agent records owners partly on a blockchain, so moving the token moves the security. The format does not change how the federal securities laws apply.
- DTC token: a DTC participant's existing entitlement to a DTC-held share, recorded on a blockchain. The share stays registered to Cede & Co., DTC's nominee, and Nasdaq's rule lets the token trade under the same CUSIP, on the same order book.
- Third-party token: issued by a firm with no tie to the company. A custodial token is an entitlement to a share the firm holds; a synthetic token is the firm's own note, swap or derivative that tracks the price. Holders of either may face the firm's own risks, "such as bankruptcy", in the SEC staff's words.
Whether a product is legal in the US, or safe to hold, depends on which of the three it is and who stands between holder and company. The SEC staff statement draws the same lines: tokens issued by or for the company, custodial tokens and synthetic tokens. Neither US trading lane opened since March 2026 admits synthetic tokens.
Four Steps to Nasdaq, Then a Second Lane
On 11 December 2025, Jeffrey S. Mooney, an associate director in the SEC's Division of Trading and Markets, signed a no-action letter to The Depository Trust Company (DTC). The staff would not recommend enforcement against DTC under Regulation SCI, the rule-filing requirements of Section 19(b) and certain clearing-agency standards during a pilot of its tokenization service. Eligible securities are Russell 1000 stocks, US Treasury bills, notes and bonds, and ETFs tracking major indices such as the S&P 500 and Nasdaq-100. The letter is withdrawn three years after the pilot launches.
DTCC's July release calls it a letter "authorizing DTC to operate a tokenization service". The letter itself says it "expresses the Staff's position on enforcement action only" and "does not purport to express any legal conclusions".
On 28 January 2026, three SEC divisions, Corporation Finance, Investment Management, and Trading and Markets, published a Statement on Tokenized Securities. It defines a tokenized security as a security "formatted as or represented by a crypto asset, where the record of ownership is maintained in whole or in part on or through one or more crypto networks." A footnote fixes its status: staff views, not a rule of the Commission, with "no legal force or effect".
On 18 March 2026, in Release 34-105047, the SEC approved Nasdaq's rule change SR-NASDAQ-2025-072, as modified by Amendment No. 2. The Division of Trading and Markets issued the order for the Commission under delegated authority. A tokenized share may trade on the same order book as its traditional counterpart, with the same execution priority, only if it is fungible with that share, carries the same CUSIP number and trading symbol, and gives the same rights and privileges.
The order lists what "same rights" includes: an equity interest in the company, dividends, voting rights and a share of residual assets on liquidation. Eligibility follows the DTC pilot without Treasuries, covering Russell 1000 stocks and ETFs tracking major indices. Fees, market data and T+1 settlement stay as they are for traditional shares. In its filing, Nasdaq said it would alert members in an Equity Trader Alert at least 30 calendar days before tokenized trading begins.
On 15 July 2026, DTCC converted DTC-held assets into tokens and used them in production trades with more than 30 firms. The conversions ran on Besu, which DTCC calls its private network, and on Canton, a public network. The workflows covered a collateral pledge, securities lending, a US Treasury repo settled delivery-versus-payment, equity trades settled against payment and against delivery, an equity token transfer and central counterparty margin. DTCC set the service's launch for October 2026.
The DTCC Tokenization Service will institutionalize tokenized markets on day one and will be a critical enabler of the digital ecosystem of the future, while reinforcing trust, safety and scale in a digital world. — Frank La Salla, President and CEO, DTCC
A fifth document opened a second lane. On 17 September 2026 the Commission issued the "Innovation Exemption", Release 34-106402: a five-year, conditional exemption from the definition of "exchange" for Tokenized Securities Venues that trade tokenized listed stock through permissioned automated market makers on public, permissionless blockchains. Unlike the staff statement, it is a Commission order, and its definitions follow the staff's sorting closely.
What a DTC Token Is, and What It Is Not
A DTC token creates no new security and leaves the share in the chain it already sits in. Under the no-action letter, a participant instructs DTC to tokenize its entitlement; DTC moves the securities from the participant's account to a Digital Omnibus Account on its central ledger and mints a token to a wallet the participant has registered. The securities "remain registered in the name of Cede & Co., DTC's nominee." Burning the token reverses the steps.
The legal frame is Article 8 of the Uniform Commercial Code, under which, DTC's request explains, DTC is a "securities intermediary" and each participant holds "security entitlements". The token records that entitlement on a blockchain instead of DTC's book-entry ledger, and LedgerScan, an off-chain scanner, keeps DTC's official record of who holds which token. DTC deals only with the participant tied to a registered wallet; the participant's relationship with its customer stays "a bilateral matter".
The token carries its own controls. Tokens move only between registered wallets, and DTC keeps a "root wallet" that can force a transfer or conversion to deal with corporate actions, erroneous entries, lost tokens or malfeasance. The request names ERC 3643 as an example of a protocol with those features, and DTCC's product page lists mint, burn, pause and clawback controls.
The token is a new format for a position in the existing indirect holding system, not direct registered ownership. DTCC calls the tokens "digital twins". It says they are designed to carry "the same legal rights, economic interest and investor protections" as the underlying securities.
The SEC staff statement does not discuss DTC's service in its text. It cites the DTC letter only in a footnote to its description of the tokenized security entitlement, the custodial model in its third-party half. That footnote first sends readers to a 2010 SEC concept release on the proxy system for "a more fulsome description of the indirect system of ownership", and only then adds "See also" the no-action letter.
Custodial and Synthetic Wrappers
A token from a firm with no tie to the company falls in the staff statement's third-party half, which has two models. A custodial token represents a security held in custody, such as a tokenized security entitlement. A synthetic token is the third party's own security: a linked security that "is not an obligation of the issuer of the referenced security and confers no rights or benefits from the issuer", or a security-based swap, which "typically does not convey to the holder any equity, voting, information, or other rights".
For both models the staff added a warning: "holders of the crypto asset may be exposed to risks with respect to the third party, such as bankruptcy, to which a holder of the underlying security would not necessarily be exposed." Such a token "may or may not" confer any rights as a holder of the underlying security, the statement says. Whether a third-party token is a share therefore depends on its documents.
Robinhood's European stock tokens show the synthetic side in a retail product. Robinhood Europe, UAB, a Lithuanian investment firm, describes them in its Key Information Document of 1 July 2026 as an over-the-counter derivative: a contract with Robinhood Europe, represented by a blockchain token. "Holding the Product does not mean you own any shares or units," the document says, and it confers no voting rights. Robinhood Europe is "the sole counterparty to payment claims", no investor compensation scheme covers the product, and its risk class is 7 out of 7.
Robinhood's description of services adds that the contracts are cash-settled only, that the token "is non-transferable and non-assignable", and that Robinhood hedges by buying the underlying shares "for its own account" one for one. It tells clients to weigh Robinhood's creditworthiness. Read against the SEC staff's categories, the product sits with the synthetic models: the hedge shares belong to Robinhood, and the client holds a claim on Robinhood.
The executive director of ESMA, the EU's securities markets authority, drew a similar line months before the SEC staff statement. In a keynote in Dubrovnik on 1 September 2025, she turned to fintech offerings that give exposure to listed shares, or DLT-based derivatives backed by stock held through special purpose vehicles. She set out the risk in two sentences.
These tokenised instruments can provide always-on access and fractionalisation but typically do not confer shareholder rights. If structured as synthetic claims rather than direct ownership, this can create a specific risk of investor misunderstanding and underlines the need for clear communication and safeguards. — Natasha Cazenave, Executive Director, European Securities and Markets Authority
The Onchain Lane the SEC Opened in September
The Innovation Exemption does not reopen the door to synthetics. It covers stock tokenized by or for the issuer and stock tokenized by an unaffiliated third party, and its definition "does not include" a third party's own security that gives synthetic exposure, "such as a tokenized linked security or a tokenized security-based swap." Custodial third-party tokens can qualify; linked securities and swaps cannot.
A venue must verify that each token gives holders the same rights and privileges as the traditional stock: the same interest in the company, dividends, voting rights and share of residual assets in liquidation. A third-party tokenizer must pass proxy materials to holders at no cost to the issuer or the shareholders. For a third-party token the issuer gets a veto: the venue must send it written notice, wait at least 30 calendar days, and keep the token off the venue if the issuer objects in time.
The exemption sets tight limits. Tier 1 tokenized stocks are capped at 75 symbols and 0.25 percent of the prior month's average daily share volume, Tier 2 at 250 symbols and 2.5 percent. Smart contracts must be auditable, public and deployed on a public, permissionless ledger; primary issuance is barred; and trading must stop whenever the listing exchange stops trading in the underlying stock. The exemption expires five years after publication.
Passing the rights test does not remove the intermediary. A custodial token on such a venue still depends on a third party that holds the real share, so the staff's warning about that party's own risks still applies. The exemption adds a trading venue outside the exchanges, for a capped slice of volume.
Collateral, Hours and Margin: What the Blockchain Changes
Tokenization changes how positions move. DTC's request says participants could use tokens for repos, securities lending, pledges and transfers much as they use book entries now. The main difference, it says, is that instead of a participant instructing DTC to make a transfer, the participant or its customer moves the token to the transferee's registered wallet, and DTC records the move through LedgerScan. The request adds that tokens would go beyond what is feasible with book entries: they could move "at any time, rather than only during DTC's hours of operation." The July trades exercised several of those uses, from a collateral pledge to a Treasury repo.
The pilot keeps DTC's own risk management out of it. DTC gives tokenized entitlements no collateral or settlement value in its Net Debit Cap or Collateral Monitor, so DTC would not rely on tokens to manage a participant's default. Any delivery-versus-payment settlement happens "away from and without any involvement by DTC". Collateral value appears only among the changes DTC "would consider" for later versions.
Trading hours are moving on their own track. Nasdaq told members in August 2026 that it will add a 9 p.m. to 4 a.m. ET session on 6 December 2026; DTCC's timeline lists December 2026 for the first exchanges to trade 23 hours a day, five days a week, after its NSCC clearing moved to a 24x5 model on 28 June 2026. A token can change wallets at any hour, but a Nasdaq trade that delivers one still settles T+1 through DTC.
Stablecoins have reached derivatives margin. Circle's results release of 5 August 2026 said Marex had enabled "the first stablecoin-powered initial margin transaction in regulated derivatives clearing", letting institutional clients post USDC as collateral for CFTC-regulated derivatives. Circle tied it to the CFTC staff no-action position of 8 December 2025 for futures commission merchants that accept payment stablecoins as customer margin. Marex announced the service in July 2026.
The same Circle release said DTCC "will enable the tokenization" of DTC-custodied assets on Arc, Circle's network, and that BlackRock is expected to deploy its BUIDL fund there. For scale: on 20 October 2026, rwa.xyz listed $14.50 billion of tokenized US Treasury products in its "distributed" category, with BUIDL at about $2.17 billion. None of that is a tokenized Nasdaq share.
Who the Route Favours, and What Is Still Pending
Read together, the documents favour whoever keeps the record of the share. Nasdaq's rule admits only DTC entitlements under the same CUSIP, with Cede & Co. still the registered owner. The Innovation Exemption admits a third-party token only if it delivers the shareholder's rights, which means someone must hold the real share, and only if the issuer does not object. Synthetic exposure, the kind of product ESMA's executive director said "typically" confers no shareholder rights, fits neither US lane.
DTCC sits at the centre of that structure. Its depository provided custody and asset servicing for securities valued at $114 trillion in 2025, per DTCC; it is among the founding validators Circle named for Arc; and its tokens are the only kind Nasdaq's approved rule admits. Exchanges keep their order books, issuers or their agents keep the master securityholder file for issuer-sponsored tokens, and issuers gain a say over third-party tokens on the new venues.
Venues that sell price exposure gain least. A derivative cannot pass the rights test; a custodial wrapper can, but then trades on a capped venue, under an issuer veto, with its custodian's risk still attached. This reading rests on the structure of the documents and makes no forecast of market shares. Both US lanes are temporary: DTC's relief runs three years from launch, the exemption five years from publication.
When this was written, on 20 October 2026, the exchange lane still waited on two dates. DTCC had not yet announced that the service it scheduled for October was live, and Nasdaq had set no start date for tokenized trading. In the filing the SEC approved, Nasdaq said it would send the Equity Trader Alert at least 30 calendar days before the first tokenized trade, so, on that timetable and as of that date, tokenized shares could not trade on Nasdaq before the second half of November 2026. DTC's three-year relief starts counting only when the pilot launches.
Sources
- SEC Division of Trading and Markets, no-action letter to DTC with DTC's request (11 Dec 2025) sec.gov
- SEC staff, Statement on Tokenized Securities (28 Jan 2026) sec.gov
- SEC Release No. 34-105047, order approving SR-NASDAQ-2025-072 (18 Mar 2026) sec.gov
- DTCC press release, DTC-tokenized assets in production trades (15 Jul 2026) dtcc.com
- SEC Release No. 34-106402, Innovation Exemption order (17 Sep 2026) sec.gov
- SEC fact sheet, Innovation Exemption sec.gov
- SEC press release 2026-90 (17 Sep 2026) sec.gov
- DTCC Tokenization Service product page dtcc.com
- Robinhood Europe, Key Information Document, US-listed Share / ETP Derivative (1 Jul 2026) cdn.robinhood.com
- Robinhood Europe, Description of Services, Financial Instruments and Risks (from 1 Jul 2026) cdn.robinhood.com
- ESMA, Natasha Cazenave keynote, Capital Markets in the Digital Age, Dubrovnik (1 Sep 2025) esma.europa.eu
- Circle, second-quarter 2026 results release (5 Aug 2026) s206.q4cdn.com
- Marex, Marex offers clients ability to post USDC as margin for derivatives (Jul 2026) marex.com
- CFTC press release 9146-25, digital assets pilot and FCM no-action position (8 Dec 2025) cftc.gov
- Nasdaq Equity Trader Alert 2026-46, new trading hours effective 6 Dec 2026 (17 Aug 2026) nasdaqtrader.com
- DTCC, 24x5 Trading for U.S. Equity Markets dtcc.com
- rwa.xyz, Tokenized U.S. Treasury Funds dashboard (read 20 Oct 2026) app.rwa.xyz
- DTCC press room (read 20 Oct 2026) dtcc.com
- Nasdaq Equity Trader Alerts archive (read 20 Oct 2026) nasdaqtrader.com
- CantonNews, DTCC details its Tokenization Service, launch still pending (16 Oct 2026) cantonnews.org
- Nasdaq, SR-NASDAQ-2025-072, Amendment No. 2, 91 FR 4138 (30 January 2026) govinfo.gov