Skip to content
Crypto.world

The Ledger

Proposed Node Attestation Protocol would let Bitcoin holders sign statements weighted by coin value

A proposal posted to Delving Bitcoin describes a protocol for publishing statements backed by proof of control of specific Bitcoin UTXOs. It would aggregate attestations by coin value as an additional, non-binding signal alongside miner signaling.

Proposed Node Attestation Protocol would let Bitcoin holders sign statements weighted by coin value

A wider signal than miner signaling

A proposal posted to Delving Bitcoin on November 21, 2026, describes a protocol for surveying Bitcoin network participants beyond miners, using statements backed by proof of control of specific unspent transaction outputs (UTXOs). The proposal, called the Node Attestation Protocol (NAP), is intended to collect views from “economic nodes”: non-mining participants that control a meaningful proportion of the network’s economic value.

The post says miner signaling has historically been the primary way to survey support for proposed network changes, but argues that miners are not the network’s only significant constituency. NAP would add a separate signal for contentious proposals, with results assembled by an aggregator and weighted by the value of the coins backing each statement.

Statements tied to coins

Under the proposal, node operators and other participants could publish free-form key-value attestations through a new backwards-compatible peer-to-peer message pair and service bit. Nodes that support the protocol would serve attestations on request; an aggregator would collect them, check them against the current UTXO set and publish results sorted by coin weight.

Attestations would be simple string-type key-value pairs, with a maximum length of 128 bytes for each key and value and printable ASCII as the permitted character set. The proposal places no other restrictions on what participants can say, giving examples ranging from “bestmoney=bitcoin” and “favoritecolor=blue” to “bip9999=yes.” Authors seeking attestations for a proposal are encouraged to specify the canonical key name and values in its BIP.

Signatures would use BIP 322 or the legacy signmessage method, depending on the output type. The attestation itself would not lock or spend coins, and the post says messages are human-readable so that signers and hardware signing devices can display them. A holder could replace an earlier statement by publishing a new one backed by the same coins; an empty value would withdraw the statement for that key.

Limits and trade-offs

The proposal says an aggregator would count each coin once per key and remove duplicate attestations, with support weighted by the aggregate coin value behind it. Attestations would remain valid for 26,208 blocks, or about six months, before needing to be signed again. Backing coins would need to be at least 4,032 blocks old, or about four weeks, and worth at least 10,000 satoshis; the post says test networks use shorter minimum coin-age values.

NAP is described as strictly non-binding: no BIP or other network decision should be mechanically conditioned on an attestation threshold or share of support. The post characterizes the results as a human-judged indication of a proposal’s popularity or support among economic nodes, to be considered alongside miner signaling and other relevant information.

The post also identifies limitations. Participation would be self-selected, signatures could be bought, and custodians could attest using coins held for customers who do not control the keys themselves. Attestations could reveal which coins a participant controls, although the post describes them as pseudonymous and says they carry no identifying information; it also notes that signing with certain output types reveals a public key or script.

Implementation and earlier examples

The proposal points to earlier coin-weighted signaling efforts, including Bitcoinocracy, launched in 2015 during the block-size debate and relaunched by Bitcoin.com in 2017, and HODL.voting, which weighted voters’ time-locked coins by amount and duration. It also cites Ethereum’s CarbonVote as a tool used to set the default for the 2016 DAO fork.

According to the post, NAP is implemented in satd 0.7+, a full Bitcoin node implementation in Rust, and includes a reference aggregator. The protocol specification remains a draft, and the post invites feedback, saying other node implementations would be welcome once the specification has been reviewed and is more finalized.

Sources

  1. Original source Delving Bitcoin delvingbitcoin.org

Related stories

Explore

More articles