Skip to content
Crypto.world

The Ledger

CFTC Tells Court CME Has Not Shown Harm From Crypto Perps

The CFTC urged a federal court on October 16 to reject CME Group’s challenge to U.S. crypto perpetual futures, arguing the exchange has not shown imminent financial injury. The filing sharpens a dispute over whether the contracts should be regulated as futures or swaps.

CFTC Tells Court CME Has Not Shown Harm From Crypto Perps

“What increasingly concerns us is the growth in perps while the litigation is playing out.”

Jaret Seiberg, policy analyst at TD Cowen

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission is asking a federal judge to dismiss CME Group’s challenge to the agency’s treatment of cryptocurrency perpetual futures, arguing the exchange has not shown it faces imminent financial harm. The CFTC made the argument in a brief filed Friday, October 16, in the dispute over whether U.S. crypto perps can be listed as futures. CME says the contracts belong in a different regulatory category: swaps.

The CFTC disputes CME’s claim of competitive harm

The agency argues that a general claim of increased competition is not enough to give CME legal standing to sue. “Allegations of increased competition, without any plausible inference of an imminent financial injury,” do not establish that standing, the CFTC said in the filing, as quoted by CoinDesk. It also points to crypto-futures volume at CME, which it says has risen since the agency’s policy shift.

The CFTC’s brief challenges CME’s description of the market to the court. The agency says CME has told investors it has not heard demand for perpetual futures and has said the products do not substitute for the futures it already offers. “CME cannot have it one way with the court and another way with the investing public on earnings calls,” the commission argued.

A dispute over how to classify contracts with no expiry

CME filed its lawsuit on June 18, challenging the CFTC’s May 29 approval of Kalshi’s bitcoin perpetual contract as a future. In its complaint, CME argues that perpetual contracts are swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act because they have no expiration date or fixed future delivery. The exchange asks the court to vacate the approval and declare that crypto perpetual contracts are swaps, not futures.

Perpetual futures let traders take positions on an asset’s price without a built-in expiry. Their classification matters because futures and swaps fall under different regulatory frameworks. The CFTC’s May action approved Kalshi’s bitcoin product and set out a policy for handling similar contracts, while CME argues the agency cannot treat these no-expiry products as futures.

The court fight leaves the market question open

The CFTC had already asked the court to dismiss CME’s suit in September; its October 16 filing further develops the agency’s argument that CME lacks standing. The commission is contesting whether CME has shown an actual or imminent competitive injury, rather than asking the judge at this stage to resolve every question about the contracts’ legal classification.

TD Cowen policy analyst Jaret Seiberg said the exchange may still have an advantage on both its standing argument and its claim that perpetuals should be treated as swaps. But growth in the market while the case proceeds could make a later remedy more difficult, he warned. The immediate question before the court is whether CME can continue its challenge at all.

Sources

  1. Original source CoinDesk coindesk.com

Other pages read

  1. CourtListener / Court filing courthousenews.com

Related stories

Explore

More articles