The Ledger
Study Records $3.97M in Unitemized DEX Hook Revenue
A study of Uniswap v4 and PancakeSwap Infinity records $3.97 million in revenue from Hooks that can deduct tokens beyond standard pool fees. The researchers found such charges in 59.23% of accounted swaps involving charging-capable Hooks through August 1, 2026.

A PancakeSwap trade shows what the fee display missed
A PancakeSwap Infinity trade in the study’s example quotes 1,227K HXIC for 1.17 USDT, while the interface lists 0.12 USDT in standard pool fees. During settlement, the pool calculates 1,496K HXIC in output, and the attached Hook retains the excess 269K HXIC—about 18% of that output. The trader still receives the quoted amount, but the fee breakdown does not itemize the Hook’s deduction.
Source arxiv.org
The example appears in a study submitted to arXiv on October 27 by Kai Ma, Tianle Sun, Shun Zhou, Boyao Yang, Ningyu He and Haoyu Wang. The researchers examined 7,873 Hook deployments and 50,011 pools on Uniswap v4 and PancakeSwap Infinity across Ethereum and BNB Smart Chain, covering activity through August 1, 2026. Their dataset includes roughly 296 million pool events.
Researchers trace $3.97 million in Hook revenue
Hooks are contracts that customize pool behavior, including what a trader pays or receives during settlement. The researchers used bytecode analysis to identify Hooks capable of extra deductions, then reconstructed historical transactions to distinguish those charges from exchanged tokens and standard pool fees. They identified charging capability in 1,913 Hooks, or 24.30% of the registered deployments.
Among 2,482,619 swaps for which the researchers could establish whether an additional deduction occurred, 1,470,344 included one—a rate of 59.23%. The frequency varied by venue: 75.76% on BSC Uniswap v4, 69.79% on PancakeSwap Infinity’s concentrated-liquidity pools, and 43.53% on Ethereum Uniswap v4.
Revenue accounting found $3,965,281.97 across 1,044 Hooks with priced revenue. The figure includes direct token transfers and newly created protocol claims, which can later be redeemed; it is not a complete total for every charge. The paper says unpriced charges were excluded and cautions that the reported figure is not necessarily a lower bound.
“These findings reveal a gap between standard fee displays and actual trading costs, motivating explicit disclosure of Hook deductions alongside standard fees.”
Kai Ma, Tianle Sun, Shun Zhou, Boyao Yang, Ningyu He and Haoyu Wang, authors of the study
Per-swap costs vary sharply by chain
Across 1,426,116 charging swaps with fully reconciled deductions and accepted historical prices, the median additional cost was $0.17 and the mean was $2.79. One Ethereum swap had an additional cost of $9,793.97. Average charges were $8.17 per priced swap on Ethereum Uniswap v4, compared with less than $0.41 on BSC Uniswap v4 and PancakeSwap Infinity’s concentrated-liquidity pools.
The researchers also compared Hook deductions with standard pool fees where both could be priced. Among 110,198 charging swaps with positive standard-fee rates and comparable prices, the Hook charge exceeded the standard fee in 82,665 cases, or 75.01%. The comparison applies to that subset, not to all swaps in the study.
The study measures fee accounting, not intent
The paper uses “undisclosed” for deductions that bypass standard pool-fee parameters and therefore do not appear as separate items in fee breakdowns based on those parameters. It does not establish that every affected interface omitted every form of disclosure, or that Hook developers acted maliciously. The authors also note that bounded execution and unresolved contract dependencies may cause their analysis to miss charging paths.
Their recommendation is for trading interfaces to list Hook deductions alongside standard fees and show expected payment and output before a trade, then report actual deductions after settlement. The study’s central finding is narrower and measurable: a quoted output can match what a trader receives even when the displayed fee breakdown leaves an additional settlement deduction unitemized.
Sources
- Original source · Preprint An Empirical Study of Undisclosed Charges in Hook-Based Decentralized Exchanges arXiv:2610.36682