Skip to content
Crypto.world

The Ledger

Thailand’s Supreme Court Rules Bitcoin Counts as Property in Robbery Case

Thailand’s Supreme Court ruled that Bitcoin can count as property in a Koh Samui robbery case involving a forced transfer of 2.480801 BTC. The court upheld a 10-year prison sentence and an order to return the Bitcoin or pay 1.878 million baht.

Thailand’s Supreme Court Rules Bitcoin Counts as Property in Robbery Case

Thailand’s Supreme Court has ruled that Bitcoin can count as property in a robbery case, rejecting a defendant’s argument that the cryptocurrency lacked value. The decision, judgment No. 4929/2569, arose from a forced transfer on Koh Samui and upholds a 10-year prison sentence for a man who helped the robbers.

Source coindesk.com

The court summary, published on October 28, says the victim was forced to exchange $50,000 for 2.480801 BTC and transfer it to the attackers. The ruling treats the Bitcoin as property taken in the robbery, rather than as money the court had to recognize as legal tender.

Why the court counted Bitcoin as property

The defendant argued that Bitcoin had no intrinsic value and could not qualify as property for the offense. The Supreme Court’s plenary bench disagreed, citing Bitcoin’s market price, its ability to be exchanged for cash when buyers are available, and the fact that people can hold it.

“The value of the money transferred as property therefore fulfills the elements of an offense against property.”

Thailand’s Supreme Court, in an English translation of the court summary published by CoinDesk

The court also considered Thailand’s 2018 Digital Asset Business Decree, which defines cryptocurrency as electronic data created on a network for use as a medium of exchange. A letter from the Bank of Thailand said cryptocurrency is not legal tender, but that status did not prevent the court from treating Bitcoin as property in this criminal case.

A forced transfer on Koh Samui

The case began with a September 2022 robbery on the island. Five foreign men threatened and assaulted the victim before forcing him to convert $50,000 into Bitcoin and send it to them. The defendant challenged his conviction; the court found that the transfer did not lose its property character when the victim’s money became cryptocurrency.

The Supreme Court upheld the 10-year sentence. The lower court had set a 15-year term, then reduced it by one-third because useful evidence from the defendant assisted the proceedings. It also ordered the Bitcoin returned to the victim or payment of 1.878 million baht, the amount associated with the transfer.

The ruling is about criminal property, not currency

The decision addresses whether Bitcoin can be the property taken in a robbery under Thai criminal law. It does not make Bitcoin legal tender or establish that the cryptocurrency must be treated as money for other legal purposes. The court’s reasoning, as reported in its summary, turns on value and the ability to hold or exchange the asset.

The distinction matters in the case’s practical outcome: the court upheld both the prison term and the return-or-compensation order. The Supreme Court’s conclusion applies to the criminal dispute before it; the ruling does not, by itself, resolve every question about Bitcoin’s status in civil disputes, taxation or financial regulation.

Sources

  1. Original source CoinDesk coindesk.com

Other pages read

  1. Siam Blockchain siamblockchain.com
  2. Bitcoin Addict bitcoinaddict.com
  3. The Thaiger thethaiger.com

Related stories

Explore

More articles